Soapbox time, where the fandom expresses its opinions! As always, we are open for submissions on these. If you'd like to submit your own soapbox, hit up this post for infos.
As always, these are the opinions of fandom members, not us here at EQD.
Have some headlines:
- My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic #1 (BOOM! Studios) is a Delight!
- MLP and Hyperborea
- Why there are 6 Elements in Equestria but 7 in the Human World: The role of Stygian, Starlight, and the Tree's "Subconscious Seed"
- Hasbro should've made Pony Blu-rays instead of doing the eOne merger
- Will Friendship is Magic Ever Be Released on Blu-ray?
And go read them below!
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic #1 (BOOM! Studios) is a Delight!
by Andrew Laubacher
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic (2026 series) #1, written by Seanan McGuire, illustrated by Amy Mebberson, colored by Joana Lafuente, is a promising first issue. Right off the start we have a gorgeous cover by Ms. Mebberson (as well as several variants by such artistic luminaries as Andy Price, Nicholetta Baldari, Jennifer Meyer, Katie Cook, Trung Le Nguyen, and Mebberson herself. Our story begins sometime after the appearance of Princess Twilight Sparkle's Castle of Friendship with preparations being made by Rarity, Pinkie Pie, Rainbow Dash and Applejack for a "surprise" birthday party for Fluttershy. Shenanigans lead to accidental damage to a rare book belonging to Twilight. The ponies are determined to fix their mess and find Twilight a replacement copy (if possible). With goal in mind, the Mane Six (and Spike) set out for Picca-Filly Circus, the place where the original volume was acquired.
This is going to be a multi-issue arc that will apparently run for the entire five issues of this initial series (I presume that if sales are good, the comic will become an ongoing series). I think it's off to a pretty good start. This is more of a slice-of-life kind of story than an epic adventure; however, the plot caught my interest, McGuire seems to have a good handle on the personalities and speech cadences of the Mane Six, and Mebberson's artwork is a delight. Add the vibrant colors of Joana Lafuente and I am eagerly looking forward to the next issue. If there's anything missing, it is the lack of a cover gallery or any text piece by the creative team. It is also my understanding that the comic will probably not include a letter column (at least not for the foreseeable future).
What this comic does accomplish it to set up some new characters and locations that we should encounter in the upcoming issues in the form of a broken friendship between the mares Posey Pen and Merry Weather from the town of Seaward Shoals. We get to see them here as fillies and I expect that we will meet both of them soon as adults. Can the Mane Six solve their friendship problem? I'm sure that they will and it should be very entertaining for us readers.
MLP and Hyperborea
By KnightFluttershy
Hyperborea is a very important concept in mythology and history; it is the idea of a land, far to the North, that exists as a paradise, removed from the rest of the world and more advanced, like Atlantis. But does this have any influence in MLP?
I would argue that The Crystal Empire is MLP's version of Hyperborea. Like Hypoerborea, it is a paradise, magically far in advance of anywhere in Equestria, that was kept in stasis and seems to exist removed and unaffected by the rest of Equestria-Celestia even implies that the state of the Crystal Empire determined the fate of Equestria itself. Yet furthermore, Hyperborea is often represented by the North Star, that is, a six pointed star made up of two interpocking concave-kite shapes. The North Star represents a point that never changes, that the world revolves around and that determines the world's fate. And if we look at the paths of the Cryatal Empire, from above, we see this exact shape! Yet there is one last piece of the puzzle, for we have seen a North Star somewhere else...Twilight Sparkle's Cutie Mark. Now it begins to make sense why Twilight's destiny was so tied up with the fate of the Empire; Celestia knew, as soon as she had seen the star appear on Twilight, who thr next Alicorn Princess would be. There may be more that I have missed, but this is as far down the Hyperborea MLP rabbit hole I have gone.
Why there are 6 Elements in Equestria but 7 in the Human World: The role of Stygian, Starlight, and the Tree's "Subconscious Seed"
I have a theory that completely solves one of the biggest lore mysteries in the MLP franchise and explains why Equestria has 6 Elements, while the human world (Equestria Girls) suddenly ended up with 7.
Part 1: Stygian’s Subconscious Seed and the True Formula of Harmony
We all know there were six Pillars of Old Equestria, and Stygian was the seventh—the one who brought them together. He didn't plant a physical artifact into the ground because he had already turned into the Pony of Shadows by then. However, he still planted his "seed" subconsciously.
The Pillars only stood together at the origin of the Tree of Harmony because Stygian united them. The Tree is a sentient entity; it absorbed not just the power of the artifacts, but the very essence of their bond (Friendship/Unity). Since there was no physical artifact from Stygian, the Tree fused his concept of Friendship directly into Starswirl's element of Magic. This is why Magic and Friendship became inseparable in Twilight Sparkle’s single crystal. If the Pillars had lived out their lives peacefully and made amends, Stygian would have left his own artifact (like his journal or quill), and Equestria would have had 7 physical elements from the very beginning.
If readers bring up the ancient book from the pilot episode, the answer is simple: the book was written from a limited historical perspective (likely by Starswirl or his followers) before they understood the true nature of the elements.
The real formula of Harmony is actually a 7-step process:
- The 5 Base Elements (Honesty, Kindness, Laughter, Generosity, Loyalty) form the foundation.
- Friendship (Stygian's legacy / Twilight's core) acts as the 6th element that unites them.
- Magic is actually the 7th element—the ultimate crown that ignites only after true friendship is achieved.
As a rule: if you have friendship, but people constantly lie or betray you, friendship breaks, and the magic disappears. Magic is the result, not the starting point.
Part 2: Twilight vs. Starlight — Friendship vs. Raw Magic
This exact concept explains the power balance in the main show. Starlight Glimmer is canonically stronger than Twilight in raw, academic magic. That’s because Twilight actually embodies Friendship (Stygian's legacy), while Starlight took the place of Magic (Starswirl's legacy).
In ancient times, Magic (Starswirl) rejected Friendship (Stygian) and banished him. In modern times, the Tree corrected this mistake: Friendship (Twilight) accepted Magic (Starlight) as her successor, eventually making her the Headmare of the School of Friendship.
We see the culmination of this in the Season 7 finale ("Shadow Play"). When Starswirl stubbornly tries to banish Stygian again, Starlight stands up to him. She doesn't fight; she uses communication and her own past experience as a reformed villain to open his eyes. This was Starlight's ultimate exam as the new embodiment of "Pure Magic"—she taught the old Magic (Starswirl) how to listen to Friendship (Twilight).
Part 3: The Tree’s Safety Measure in the Human World
When Equestria’s magic first leaked through the portal into the human world, it encountered a completely foreign, "dry" environment with no innate spells, alicorns, or magic in the inhabitants' blood.
In Equestria, ponies can eventually channel harmony internally without the physical stones because magic is part of their biology. Humans do not have innate magic, so they must rely on physical crystals as mandatory conductors. Furthermore, without a proper anchor, the human group easily falls apart.
The sentient magic realized that the Equestrian system—where Magic and Friendship are crammed into a single host (Twilight)—was too risky for humans. A human mind simply couldn't handle the simultaneous burden of massive empathetic energy and raw cosmic power. To prevent another tragedy, the magic in the human world split this "combo-element" into two independent crystals:
1. Sci-Twi (Human Twilight) received the crystal of raw physical magic and levitation (the counterpart to Starswirl/Starlight).
2. Sunset Shimmer received the seventh crystal: Empathy.
Sunset became Stygian’s true counterpart—the glue and the heart of the team. This 7th physical crystal acts as a forced magnetic anchor; as long as Sunset is there to hold them together, the other six crystals can function. Thus, the human world corrected the compressed nature of Equestrian magic by granting Unity its own separate, seventh physical stone.
Part 4: Anticipating Counterarguments (Season 9, Comics, and the Future)
To address potential counterarguments regarding the final season and IDW comics #100-102:
- Other Trees and World Harmony: If readers point out other trees and "lightbulbs" lighting up across the world (like with Zecora in Farasi or the cats of Abyssinia), the explanation is simple: those elements' seeds had already spread long before Twilight's time, whenever early friendship began to bloom in those lands (as Zecora is older than Twilight).
- The Young Six: As for the School of Friendship and the Young Six—their era is just beginning. They are currently operating on the foundational elements, but they might very well find their own 7th friend in the future to complete their unity and mirror this grand design!
Hasbro should've made Pony Blu-rays instead of doing the eOne merger
By FirePuppy (Tadashi Satoru)
To be honest, if Hasbro had listened to us, did not do any mergers, and just released all their 2010s My Little Pony films and series on Blu-ray, we would've been much happier than we are now. Here's how it would've worked:
In an alternate universe, in summer 2019, after finishing all production of Friendship is Magic, Equestria Girls, and Rainbow Roadtrip, instead of doing that eOne acquisition that turned out to be a failure, Hasbro would just release everything in the FiM/EG library on Blu-ray -- not just in the US, but worldwide. This would include all nine seasons of Friendship is Magic, all the rest of the Equestria Girls series that we didn't get on Blu-ray, Best Gift Ever, Rainbow Roadtrip, and the Friendship is Forever clip shows. On top of this, the Stop Motion Shorts and Pony Life would NOT exist. As a result, this would put the MLP franchise on a two-year hiatus -- about as long as the hiatus we are currently in now. However, unlike the hiatus we're in, this hiatus would be a good one for both Hasbro and the MLP fans, because it would have given Hasbro more production time to make Generation 5, and with the Blu-rays we would've gotten, more countries would be able to see what wasn't released to them as of now, and we'd have the Friendship is Forever clip shows without the 9Go watermark today.
But alas, Hasbro chose to do it their way, do the stupid thing and waste multiple times how much it would have costed them to make all those Blu-rays I mentioned -- on one pointless acquisition that did not turn out to unlock the power and value of creativity of anything. And now, all that money in which a fraction of it could have been used to release the remaining international dubs and Blu-rays for us MLP fans is instead all going to the company's bondholders, and we get NOTHING!
I mean, look at it this way. Transformers Prime, Hasbro's other flagship, got all three seasons AND the Predacons Rising movie on Blu-ray (and DVD), while MLP only got the EG films on Blu-ray and nothing else. So if they can do it to Transformers Prime, why not My Little Pony as well? What do you think about this alternate timeline?
Will Friendship is Magic Ever Be Released on Blu-ray?
By: KPackratt (Kaz Packman)
Ever since My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic ended in 2019, I've been hoping for a complete series Blu-ray release so we could watch the series in Full HD without commercials or having to worry about it vanishing from a streaming service (which is precisely what happened to Seasons 5-9 on Netflix in 2022), but so far there haven't been any announcements made regarding a Blu-ray release for the series.
Hasbro has missed two anniversary release windows: the 10th anniversary in 2020 and the 15th in 2025, which has really disappointed me as those were the perfect opportunities to release a Blu-ray box set of the series.
In addition, Shout Factory hasn't released a single new My Little Pony DVD since 2019, so Hasbro would have to either renew their licensing agreement with Shout Factory or license the series to another distributor. With Paramount merging with Warner Bros. Discovery (who owned the US broadcast rights), it would be nice if Paramount could release it since they formerly released the G3 cartoons on DVD and VHS back in the 2000s.
I hope that the upcoming live-action My Little Pony movie for 2027 will give Hasbro the incentive to release the complete series of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic on Blu-ray as a tie-in, since Universal has recently released the 1980s He-Man and the Masters of the Universe TV series on Blu-ray as a tie-in for the franchise's live-action movie and Disney had released the Chip and Dale Rescue Rangers TV series as a tie-in for its Disney+ live-action movie in 2022.
If the Equestria Girls movies, Bluey, Adventure Time, and The Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog can get Blu-ray releases, then what's stopping Hasbro from licensing My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic for a complete series Blu-ray release?
Considering Sony has announced that there will be no more PlayStation game discs released beginning in 2028, which has people worried that physical movie/TV show releases will eventually suffer from a similar fate, I'm really hoping that Hasbro releases it sooner rather than later because the future of physical media is in an uncertain position right now.






















