#3 would be perfect for RD and AJ. :P There just aren't enough Luna clips to really make that work. They did a good job for what they had to work with though.
Love Defying Gravity. Probably one of my favorite showtunes of all time. And I also really like Wicked. That PMV is downright horrible though. Elphaba's the hero; it just doesn't work as NMM's song. Plus, too many reused clips. Downright shame.
I appreciate the criticism, and trust me, I also believe that, in the end, had I more clips, this could have turned out better than its current state. However, since I had little to work with, I did what I could. And also remember the fact Elphaba is the Wicked Witch of the West, who in The The Wonderful Wizard of Oz is the villain; Wicked does a role reversal. So I had to do the same here to remain true to the book, show, and piece of music. I'm sorry it didn't like up to your expectations, but there were some circumstances and design choices that limited me.
1. Even though I've never tried Angry Birds, I hate it with a passion because it is so casual and mainstream. Liked the video though. 2. ohgodpinkie 3. Boring, not my kind of music.
I'm very sorry, but huge thumbs down on #3. It's just random clips of Twi and NMM set to music. I've thought before that AJ and RD would be perfect for this song... maybe I'll work on my own version.
3- great, though I would more prefer Rarity as Glinda and Rainbow Dash/Twilight Sparkle to be Elphaba. I love Wicked though. It's the best musical ever, so it needs experienced bronies to use it for a PMV.
Confound these ponies! They drive me to recognize and appriciate musical songs. Never heard of Wicked before MLP. Too bad there's such little footage of Luna and Nightmare moon.
27 comments:
I love #3. <333
Loved the first video
Can't watch the other 2 on a mobile :(
#3 start is the cutest thing i've ever seen. even cuter than fs.
whats #3 song from?
Wow, so someone else out there has heard of "Tommy".
@Gavin
Wicked
Oh my, the first was brilliant!
#3 would be perfect for RD and AJ. :P There just aren't enough Luna clips to really make that work. They did a good job for what they had to work with though.
Hey Seth, what did ya mean by:
Good news: I've cleared out a lot of the fanfiction from my email troubles. Tomorrow should be much less spammy.
???
I sent you my fanfic. was it good? just asking...
Wow. Ponies really do go with everything. Even when you only use one episode for all of your footage. Great job #3. <3
#1 is really really awesome
#2 is very nice. very well done
i have no opinion on #3
yeah Wicked!
All these PMVs are great, espec. the Wicked one, but they aren't as awesome as PINKIE, THE EMISSARY OF DARKNESS.
Love Defying Gravity. Probably one of my favorite showtunes of all time. And I also really like Wicked. That PMV is downright horrible though. Elphaba's the hero; it just doesn't work as NMM's song. Plus, too many reused clips. Downright shame.
@Anonymous
I appreciate the criticism, and trust me, I also believe that, in the end, had I more clips, this could have turned out better than its current state. However, since I had little to work with, I did what I could. And also remember the fact Elphaba is the Wicked Witch of the West, who in The The Wonderful Wizard of Oz is the villain; Wicked does a role reversal. So I had to do the same here to remain true to the book, show, and piece of music. I'm sorry it didn't like up to your expectations, but there were some circumstances and design choices that limited me.
1. Even though I've never tried Angry Birds, I hate it with a passion because it is so casual and mainstream. Liked the video though.
2. ohgodpinkie
3. Boring, not my kind of music.
I really should be trying to write now, but this was worth it. The first and last ones were outstanding, but I'm not sure what o make of the second.
Somepony do "Hear me, Feel me." Actually just do the entire "Tommy" album.
@Anonymous
I mean "See me, Feel me"
1 = awesomeness!!!
@Anonymous
I think Pinball Wizard might be a bit problematical.
But oh dear, now I'm seeing Zecora in The Acid Queen.
I'm very sorry, but huge thumbs down on #3. It's just random clips of Twi and NMM set to music.
I've thought before that AJ and RD would be perfect for this song... maybe I'll work on my own version.
To all the people who want Tommy PMVs...
We'll see. :)
Zecora, the Acid Queen? XD
1) YEEEEESSSSS!!!
2) Not bad. Plus, Tommy's awesome.
3) Meh.
3- great, though I would more prefer Rarity as Glinda and Rainbow Dash/Twilight Sparkle to be Elphaba. I love Wicked though. It's the best musical ever, so it needs experienced bronies to use it for a PMV.
I liked 3 for the song. The clips fit well but they got old really fast (repeats the nightmare moon scenes like 5 times)
Confound these ponies! They drive me to recognize and appriciate musical songs.
Never heard of Wicked before MLP.
Too bad there's such little footage of Luna and Nightmare moon.
Post a Comment