[Sad]
Author: Strange Phantasm
Description: A chain of events leads the Cutie Mark Crusaders to discover a terrible secret locked away beneath Canterlot Castle. A secret that will change the history of Equestria, forever.She Will Be Loved Part 1
She Will Be Loved Part 2
She Will Be Loved Part 3
She Will Be Loved Part 4 (New!)
Additional Tags: Grief, Love, Hope, Friendship, Magic
59 comments:
hey, a chapter format. me gusta.
ReplyDeleteI love Scootaloo fics. -hugs-
ReplyDeleteLove that song <3 but I'm not in the mood for sad
ReplyDeleteHmm, interesting. Will read later.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteMaroon 5 YES
ReplyDeleteSad Scootaloo? It's always that or a chicken joke. May read, sounds interesting.
ReplyDeletemore scootabuse? >_>
ReplyDelete+ 5 Internets to the first commenter for not saying first.
ReplyDeleteOhhh boy. Sad tags are a reppellant for a lot of people, but they are a MAGNET for me. I absolutely must read every sad story I see on this website. Because I love that feeling of empathy they cause.
ReplyDeleteWill read, after I finish my physics homework. guhhhh
Scootaloo
ReplyDeleteSad
Why do we love making Scoots sad so often? Gonna read this later.
Sad tag just means there is sad content not that the entire story is sad or has a bad ending. Big difference between a Scootasad story where Dash finds out she is an orphan and adopts her and A Scootasad story where she dies alone and everyone cries, the end.
ReplyDeleteThe description for this sounds like neither of those but who knows what future chapters have in store.
Oh and authors? Please stop referencing the G3.5 Scootaloo slogan. It gives me nightmares.
ReplyDeletelol read all 5 chapters so far, its pretty good and is making for a decent story. just to quell a bit of the "sad" turnoff thoughts, has nothing to do with scootaloo dying, has to do with her life, and its not a constant downer
ReplyDeleteGrrr it's not loading for me. Just takes me to my doc history.
ReplyDeleteThis is great so far, keep up the good work!
ReplyDelete-spoiler-
ReplyDeleteOh is Scootaloo gonna learn necromancy?
I hope she learns necromancy... *gasp* maybe she will use it to bring back her dead mother 0.0 or at least try.
I really love this story. The OC pony I've seen so far is really, really cool.
ReplyDeleteAgh! It takes me to my fic history! (which is probably about as long as the fic, sadly)
ReplyDeleteCall me crazy, but the sad, character-bending, somewhat possible concepts always make me really happy.
ReplyDeleteCall me crazy, but the sad, character-bending, potentially possible stories always make me really happy.
ReplyDeletesorry for the double post, log-in glitch.
ReplyDeleteHey guys, author here. Thanks for the comments so far. Since some people seem to be having problems with the story loading, here is the address for Chapter 1. I've added forward/back links at the bottom of the chapters as they apply. Once again, thanks for reading!
ReplyDeletehttps://docs.google.com/document/d/1P9WK8HgO5ZU4hHQUJrXTgbP2YG42ohoPWHv7bWxDMl0/edit
Just confirming that so far it appears not to be a "sad" story in a sense. You could nearly toss in the adventure tag too.
ReplyDeleteI believe the sad stems more from Scootaloo's family.
I can't believe what is happening here. I was gasping at every shocking bit. I want MOOOOAAARR!!
ReplyDeleteOops, looks like that was the wrong one. Here is the correct address.
ReplyDeletehttps://docs.google.com/leaf?id=1P9WK8HgO5ZU4hHQUJrXTgbP2YG42ohoPWHv7bWxDMl0&sort=name&layout=list&pid=0B-XykMIHqKPRNzA3MTc2OTItNmE0Zi00YzY5LWEzZTgtYjBlNjEwYmViYTAw
I'll be keeping an eye on this one for sure. I do wish the chapters would be longer.
ReplyDeleteI'm also glad it's actually consistant with other fanfics (looking at PMW specifically, even complements it to a degree), whether intended or not.
Awesome story so far. I'll definitely keep an eye on it.
ReplyDeleteHas poor Scootaloo ever had a happy fic? EVER?
ReplyDeleteOne of the most interesting plots I've ever read in a mlp fic. Although the story isn't really sad. More like light grimdark or maybe even tragedy. It even has its humorous momments from time to time
ReplyDeleteStunningly well written. I want more!
ReplyDelete@Aullie96
ReplyDeleteIt is merely the first act, my dear.
@Half_A_Taco
ReplyDeleteWouldn't she have to be a unicorn to use magic? She will prolly end up aiding in the spell somehow, though.
Anyway, I finished reading chapter 5, and was like "Oh crap. Some serious shiz is going to go down in the coming stories."
I will be waiting eagerly for the next act. :3
i really want to know what happens next... bleh i hate having to wait....
ReplyDeleteI adore that picture you have there, it's so dang pretty and makes me wanna hug the both of them!
ReplyDeleteSo far, I really enjoy this story. I've come to find if i can hear the actual characters from the show talking when you are reading the story it isa very big plus. Or I'm just crazy.
Have to say the plot twisting will be interesting to see play out. Keep up the good work~!
Wow, this is really good. The new character is awesome, and I cannot wait for more.
ReplyDeleteMust read next Act II!!! Hopefully it will be on EQD as an update so I don't forget.
ReplyDeleteIs this really even sad? It's more just drama so far.
ReplyDeleteThe summary and title drew me in, and so far pretty good. I hope it doesn't go in a truly sad direction as it could....but...huh.
It's good. The chapters are really short, so I kinda get ejected from the story just as I'm getting into it, but I like what I'm reading so far. It's certainly original. Gonna see where this one goes in the future.
ReplyDeletelol all the cool sadfics are named after a sad rock song nowdays
ReplyDeleteyou left out Pinke Pie when you introduced the mane cast to Twilight's parents :p
ReplyDeleteread the first five chapters. you built the plot, felt a little rushed, but then again its better than being bogged down in 15 pages of details. but the story just didnt grab me. Chapter five idk, I just think Luna, being an immortal goddess of unimaginable power could of done something more, not to mention Dash could of just flew and caught scoots. the "bottomless" pit would have enough room for Dash to catch up and get Scootaloo. all this to a chained up and unable to use his magic unicorn. idk. I guess the suspension of disbelief to advance the plot wasnt there for me.
TL;DR good story but not for me.
keep writing! never want to discourage talent as the story was pretty well written so far.
Sorry you didn't like it, can't please everyone I guess. Thanks for catching the bit about Pinkie Pie though, it's fixed now.
ReplyDeletepretty good so far... please hold this quality in the next chapters :D
ReplyDeletewhARE IS THE NEW ACT I WANT IT NOAW!!!!
ReplyDeleteACT 2! NAO! That was SO awesome.
ReplyDeleteI've really enjoyed the story so far, but as an English major a couple of decades past, I have to get this out of my system: one winged pony is a pegasus; two or more winged ponies are pegasi (some use pegasuses, but that just doesn't seem eloquent enough). It's like hippopotamus and hippopotami.
ReplyDeletePraise Celestia for Applejack, the voice of equine reason. That scene could have gone south really fast if she hadn't been there to keep things in perspective.
And poor Spike. He's going to have faced a lifetime of drama before his wings even bud. Thank goodness he's up to it.
Really good story so far. Looking forward to the continuation.
Strange Phantasm again.
ReplyDeleteFixed all instances of pegaproblems. I hope. Once again, the author would like to thank his readers for creative criticism.
I'd also like to apologize to the readers for not finishing the work before submitting. Honestly I wasn't expecting to have such a great response. For Act 2 I'm not sure if I'll submit new chapters as they come along or just save em up till it's done. We'll see.
So far, the story is mostly well written, but had some rather weak points, too.
ReplyDeleteThe beginning is too drawn out, the entire first chapter adds nothing to the story and could be skipped (to the moment when Twilight gets the letter).
Can I just say that Dusk Shadow's escape is very badly contrived? The type of cell you can enter and not leave is good when you want to trap intruders, not when you want the world to forget about what's inside. The "bottomless pit" serves no purpose other than to allow Dusk Shadow to pull Scootaloo into it.
I also hated the flashback in chapter 8th. I think it was the worst part of the fic so far. It's boring, has no impact on the plot at all and shows us exactly nothing new about the characters (not to mentions most of those characters are dead anyway, so what's the point?). Even its narrative structure falls apart - those are supposed to be Dusk's memories, but the POV is initially Dandelion's, then it without warning jumps to Meadow Breeze (granted, it gave me a jolly moment when I thought Dandelion regrets that he has a girlfriend because he's so handsome, etc.). Why? It makes no sense.
Other than that, I may end up liking this fic - but only if the next chapters will focus less on cheesy thousand-year-old romance and more on necro-Scootaloo. ;)
On another note, this story could totally have a subtitle "Looking for Scootalove in wrong places". :D
Are the links correct? The links for parts three and four just go to the folder for part two.
ReplyDelete@JoeyH
ReplyDeleteI have the same question.
Dunno what's going on with the links, but the story is all there....
ReplyDeleteHowever, the update (from way back at Christmas) is actually part *8*. Part 7 was up last time, at least last time I read it.
it seems that this story is going to be very very great.
ReplyDeleteIts a shame that it took a pretty long time for every update
look for the girl, with the broken smile.
ReplyDeleteask'er if she wants to stay awhile...
@Melodia
ReplyDeleteIf I recall correctly, Ch1-5 were released as part I, and Ch6 and Ch7 were released as part II. Now it says there's a part III and part IV, but only one new chapter is visible. Anypony else remember if this is correct or not?
The flashback in Ch. 8, while appearing not to serve any purpose, was probably there to tell us a little more about Meadow Breeze. But yeah, the things about it being Dusk Shadow's thoughts but him not thinking anything during doesn't really make sense. Nor does the thing about switching POV's like that.
ReplyDeleteI still love the story though and will continue to read.
@JoeyH I have no idea either... I just got confused. Chapter 8, part 4..?
ReplyDeleteAlso, Parts 2-4 link to the same folder.
Also, I read Chapter 8 already.
Also, I'm confused again.
Hoping for a Chapter 9, but expecting it to show up as part 6...
which part is new? i'm so confused I read all these already Dx ;-;
ReplyDeleteWhen I submitted an update for Act 2 I didn't realize they would make a new link every time, so it's kinda confusing. There should really only be two links, one folder for Act 1 and one for Act 2.
ReplyDeleteI'm not too sure where the extra update came from myself.. o_O
About the flashback and point of view business, it was never supposed to actually be Shadow's memory and thus a pov shift should have been fine. I'll fix it to make that clearer, along with revising the "escape". Again, thanks for the feedback readers.
Scootafans are best fans.
@Strange Phantasm Is this story still alive? I'd hate to see it go; it's one of my favorites! I'd appreciate it if you could put my wonderings to rest whatever the answer. If you are still working on it, keep up the awesome work!
ReplyDeleteAlso, you should really get Seth to fix those links haha. Maybe you could put it on FIMfiction that way all the links are in one place and you get even more exposure. Other than that, I don't believe that there's anything else that I could add to help make your story better; it's perfect in my opinion!