[Normal] I knew what image this fic was based on the moment I read it.
Author: Sword_Of_Squirrels
Description: Rainbow Dash has been keeping a secret for a long time, ever since she was a young foal. Up till now, keeping that secret has been easy, but recent events have made this normally trivial task very difficult for her.
A Terrible Secret
Additional tags: Secrets, Lies, Truth, Short, Hair Care
103 comments:
Lol'd
ReplyDeleteOoooh, I wonder what the secret is.
ReplyDeletealreadyreadit.png
ReplyDeletewhat a twist!
ReplyDeleteKinda reminds me of the character of Ritz Malheur from Final Fantasy Tactics Advance. She was born the same way, and wanted to stay in Ivalice where she was finally normal the way she was, instead of having to fake it all the time.
ReplyDelete<3 Ritz
@Alexis Yeah, though it probably would have helped if she didn't dye her hair PINK in the freaking Earth realm instead of a reasonable color like brown or black.
ReplyDeleteresent=recent
ReplyDeleteSo exactly how much cooler is a rainbow mane than a plain white one? About 20%?
ReplyDeleteQuite liked it. Everyone was well in character, the story was funny, and the conclusion was heartwarming.
ReplyDeleteI daresay that this could have passed for an episode of the show, it was so well done. Great job.
Wow, that certainly was a fun read!
ReplyDeleteYou kept the characters true to themselves, and it was just such an interesting topic to mull over.
Oh that Applejack part gave WAYYY to many implications at the end
ReplyDeleteAnyways great story! Really liked how well you characterized RBD, the only thing that irked me is Rarity not figuring it out sooner, but i digress 5/5!
PONY GEAR! (It makes sense if you give it enough thought)
ReplyDelete*Grin*
ReplyDeleteI love the underlying meaning of the title. Its brilliant.
No complaints about the story or the way you wrote it. This one comes down to personal preference alone. In that light, I enjoyed it enough but there were no surprises.
@TenchiFreak5
ReplyDeleteQSA: I concur madame, or sir... These avatars are very misleading... >.>
Felt like I was reading an episode of the show. This is excellent!
ReplyDeleteI hope this is a episode in season 2. I don't care how logic defying the ponies are, rainbow hair is a bit out there.
ReplyDeleteBrilliant and clever enough to be made into an episode, with such a good lesson at the end. The ending with Derpy made me smile... Good job.
ReplyDeleteVery funny, very well-written. Also, am I the only one vaguely reminded of that episode of Cheers where it turns out Sam wears a hairpiece? Or am I the only one who sits around watching ponies AND old sitcoms?
ReplyDelete@ToonNinjaWhere everypony knows your name..."
ReplyDeleteAnimal expert afraid of bats? ACE VENTURA PET DETECTIVE.
ReplyDelete*cough*
I expected this fanfic to come along, but gosh, did it come out GREATLY. I loved it.
This'd make a great concept for an actual episode of the show.
ReplyDeleteI bet the Applejack part was inspired by fanart too. Call it a hunch, but all her fanart is a little on the EEEEEUUUUUUGGGGHHHHH side.
ReplyDelete@ToonNinja
ReplyDeleteM*A*S*H 4077th is a little more my taste bromod.
DANG IT DERPY, WHY MUST YOU RUIN EVERYTHING?!?!
ReplyDeleteWell that was enjoyable. Like others have said, I think this could pass for a real episode, but I don't really like the idea of having canon!Rainbow Dash have white hair. I prefer it to be natural.
I was imagining the scenes as if it were a real episode as I was reading this. The story is just THAT good.
ReplyDeleteI honestly think she's cuter with a white mane. Something about white hair and violet/red/pink eyes... stupid drow, creeping into my preferences.
ReplyDeleteNot sure if want.
ReplyDeleteSorry, but who the hell gives away your receipt to a different customer?
ReplyDeleteThat was a beautiful thing, thank you.
ReplyDeleteTho, picture kinda ruined the secret for me.
Yeah I know.
Re: Applejack's secret . . .
ReplyDelete. . one of the fan theories I've heard for Big Mac's injury was that it came from wearing Granny Smith's girdle. You remember, in Ticket Master AJ mentions a bet with Mac where if he lost, he'd have to wear it? Well she won the bet, soo . . .
Well
ReplyDeleteThat's our Derpy!
*Audience Laugh*
Interesting story, but it just feels too petty. Nothing in the show has lead me to believe that anyone would care about their, or anyone else's hair, that much except for Rarity.
ReplyDeleteIt's a pretty good story. I could have seen this as being in the actual show as well, though I doubt that will happen. I mean, Rainbow Dash dying her hair? I doubt they'll bring it up.
ReplyDelete@kriss1989
ReplyDeleteAaaand we now have justification for both a pony-themed bar and a bar-centered episode.
@Flaskgarg
M*A*S*H, Cheers, it's all good. All in a league of their own in terms of quality. I mean, really; how many quality shows are out there nowadays with that same kind of chemistry between the characters? Oh, only the one we have a website dedicated to.
I agree. Excellently written. If it was in screenplay format I don't see why it couldn't be an episode.
ReplyDeleteI enjoy reading stories like this. Hopefully it'll make me a better writer too.
I'm with you guys, this definitely could pass as an episode. Anyway, great story.
ReplyDeleteI felt like I was reading a pony episode. That was some really great stuff dawg =D
ReplyDeleteIt was funny, and it had a heartwarming conclusion. Quality =)
Awwww Dash... We'd all love you no matter what colour your hair was!
ReplyDelete@ToonNinjaYeah, but not sure if I'd want to watch the cast get salt-licked though.
ReplyDeleteHmm... That was a very interesting story...
ReplyDeleteWaitwaitwaitwaitwait.. What about Photofinish? She has a white mane.
ReplyDelete@jaayro
ReplyDeleteI dunno, it's more gray than pure albino white. I can't see Photo Finish's mane 'catching the light' to the degree that it almost glows.
Fun read. It felt like an episode. White maned RD looks cute.
ReplyDeleteWhat we now need is a group image of the main cast with bleached mane/tail. That will seal the deal.
@Duskfly
ReplyDeleteDone.
http://the-letter-j.deviantart.com/art/Bleached-Mane-Cast-210761365
Confound you Derpy! You drive ponies to tell the truth!
ReplyDelete@The Letter J
ReplyDeleteAwesome. You win an internet.
@The Letter J Needs to be about 20% cooler
ReplyDelete@Alexis
ReplyDeleteWow, I wasn't the only one thinking that. I nostalgiaed hard.
This is an awesome story.
ReplyDeleteI swear the writers of this show would be impressed by this.
How cool would it be if this were turned into an actual episode?
.......more than 20% cooler!
@Anonymous
ReplyDeleteBelieve me, I know. I might try to touch it up in the morning.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteGotta say, this is a pure gem. Like everypony else has said, this would make a good episode, though it would be one of those canon-shifting eps. You got yer five stars.
ReplyDeleteLove this story, very cute! Nice short little read, too. :D
ReplyDeleteAfter less than 3 hours, this already has over 50 comments and 86 ratings? Alright, I'm checking it out...
ReplyDeleteThat was very cute. The writing was a tad stiff, but it was not a large detriment.
ReplyDeleteFINALLY, A SECRET RAINBOW HAS THAT ISN'T BEING GAY. Honestly, it's getting pretty old. What can't she have regular stories? I'd even take shipping, as long as it's with a COLT this time.
ReplyDeleteGood job, I found the writing super cute. All those who haven't read it should.
ReplyDelete@s
ReplyDeleteYeah mabye a story where her secret is that shes pretending to be gay.
That would be a nice change from most of the Rainbow Dash stories out there.
Great story. Also, rainbowdash has rainbow flight trails, rather derps your imagination that this could be an episode.
ReplyDeleteI dunno, if my hair was albino and I saw my friends dye their hair white, I'd just think they were mocking me.
ReplyDeleteNitpicking aside, good story!
but i like her natural rainbow hair!
ReplyDeleteThat was awesome (even though I usually say it about all good Rainbow Dash fanfics)! How could anyone do not like it? Because it's not some kind of shipping (I think she was already shipped (does such word even exist (I'm truely sorry for these brackets)?)) or sad story, exploiting some kind of "deep" emotions (accent on EMO). Just like somepony said: it's good story that even deserves to become an episode of show.
ReplyDeleteStating the obvious, your
The Most Evil Pony
Felt like reading a script for an episode. Pretty well caught, and half the time I heard the voices when I read the lines...
ReplyDeleteWell done.
Oh Derpy... You so silly ^_^
ReplyDeleteThis is very well written, so well written that with some polishing and professional effort, i could totally see this as an episode of the show.
ReplyDeleteVery cool
I agree. This is the first piece of MLP fanfiction I've read and it was exceptional. It would make a great episode and if I thought it would get anywhere, I'd suggest we send it to Ms. Faust... Who knows?
ReplyDeleteBut yes, it was a heartwarming tale and I loved it. n.n
This is a really well written fic.
ReplyDeleteI liked Rainbow Dash's characterization and re-interpretation of her origins. That single drawing had a lot of potential to become a full blown story.
The revelation towards the end made me shed a few tears, but by the end of it I could only say one thing: "DEEEERPYYYYY!!!"
Reading this was like watching an official episode or even better! I did not even realize that I was actually reading. Amazing!
ReplyDeleteVery well written, I must say. I wouldn't be surprised if this ended up being a 6-star.
ReplyDeleteMuch gratz, Sword_of_Squirrels.
Very well written, thank you for the story.
ReplyDeleteAwww, that was rather sweet. It'd make a good episode if it wouldn't spoil the magic :)
ReplyDelete@kriss1989
ReplyDeleteJust picture this for a second: a sloshed Pinkie Pie attempting to launch into a song, but collapsing about halfway through because she can't keep her balance.
Aww :( 5/5 for an excellent RD story.
ReplyDeleteWhere are the stars? This needs all the stars!
ReplyDeleteI was impressed first of all that knowing what Rainbow Dash's secret was beforehand didn't keep me from enjoying this. I was even more impressed at her friends' solution to her problem; first in what they did, and then in what they said. All those secrets were spot-on, including Applejack's! All your characterization and dialogue were fantastic. :)
the terrible secret of space
ReplyDeleteAside from the occasional spelling error, it was a smooth and intriguing read. At times it felt like I was reading a transcript for an actual episode.
ReplyDelete> Secrets, Lies, Truth, Hair Care
ReplyDeleteBest tags ever.
@ToonNinja ...baha!OK that was good for a little chuckle. And what would we call CHEERSxMLP?
ReplyDeleteHow has this not received a six star rating yet? Beautiful!
ReplyDeleteExcellent. This story actually has a moral like those found in the animated series. It's actually refreshing. Keep up the good work.
ReplyDelete“Rainbow Dash,” Pinkie Pie yelled, “you lost your hat.”
ReplyDeleteAnd then I lost my shit.
Good times!
Ending was a bit rushed though, everything after the group hug until the cute Derpy joke at the end.
I really enjoyed this story. It flowed a lot like an actual episode with all the characters fitting their personalities pretty well. I really don't see what's the big deal. At least white hair is better than GREEN hair; what an awful color!
ReplyDeleteTwilight's secret made me lol.
ReplyDeleteI had an epiphany recently. If the show does do an episode like this, it makes for a good stand in for the issue of coming out of the closet. Just replace dyes hair with likes pussy.
ReplyDeleteOh that Derpy!
ReplyDelete*Pinkie trombone*
This should be an episode.
ReplyDeleteI think the word Terrible in the title should be in quotes.
ReplyDeleteThat minor nitpick aside, I do agree with the many posters who think this story should be turned into an episode.
I've been reading Fics for about a month now. This is an old story and I doubt many people will read this. Oh well!
ReplyDeleteI was really hesitant to read a Pony fic. 'I'm already obsessed with a little girls' show. This would just be ridiculous. These people are just weird for even writing stories about ponies,' I had thought. Then, about 3 stories later, I was hooked. Now I check EqD daily just to see if my favorite stories or authors have put out something new.
So Mr. (or Mrs?) Sword_of_Squirrels, I thank you for writing a wonderful story and getting me into pony fiction. Many wishes of magic and friendship to you.
This is such a well-done story. The characters' personalities feel right and the plot itself sounds like it would work just fine as an episode of the show. Five stars, easily!
ReplyDelete~Ardashir
@The Letter J A white mane makes Twilight look _really_ old.
ReplyDelete"Whoops..."
ReplyDeleteHad me in stitches.
Best ending this could have
I really liked it. It's episode material.
ReplyDeleteQuick someone send this to lauren faust stat!!!!
ReplyDeleteSo... no one's made fan art of her silhouetted against the night sky just after the hat fell of yet? Judging from a lot of the Luna fan art lately I think it'd be fairly epic.
ReplyDeleteWhy would Rainbow Dash need to worry about running out of liquid rainbow when she's got a waterfall made of the stuff pouring off the side of her house?
ReplyDeleteIt's okay Dashie, we still love you!
ReplyDelete(I'll be honest; I actually like white haired Rainbow more...blame Anime for giving me the fetishes)
wow i love rainbow dash was rainbow. RAINBOW dash
ReplyDeleteOh, that's wonderful. This was a beautiful story.
ReplyDeleteBut a white-haired Rainbow is just divine. Absolutely lovely.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleterainbow dahs se pinto el pelo
ReplyDeleteRed eyes and white hair... so she's albino?
ReplyDelete@nick012000
ReplyDeleteThis is explained in-story.
I didn't like it no offense. I mean her name is RAINBOW Dash. That alone proves she has a naturally rainbow colered mane. Also she's a tomboy, and she's lazy, she wouldn't bother dying her mane because well she's to lazy to. So it's naturally Rainbow colered.
ReplyDelete