Patrick: "WE SHOULD TAKE THE BRONY ARTISTS/ AND PUSH THEM INTO VOCALIST CLASSES" but no, these guy's put a lot of effort into their work and that stands for a lot. Also they do it out of the love of a community/ tv show that is totally awesome. They deserve ALL the props, but the audiophile within me still shudders from time to time x_x
@Versilaryan When I wrote that comment I had only listened to the third song. Your song I then listened to and immediately downloaded. Your singing was pretty much flawless, though your mic quality/ recording location made it seem a bit lackluster. The singing itself was great though. Also I had just finished listening to some pretty bad brony singing before viewing this post. I myself could never sing anything like your song because I, much to my chagrin, have the vocal range of half an octave. I do play/ listen to a lot of music however, cause its awesome.
@Shutterfly Haha, that's what I get for recording in a practice room. xD Problems happen when there's no natural reverb whatsoever. Thanks so much for the comment, though!
I'm sure you could expand that range a ton if you worked on it. You seem to know what you're talking about as far as sound quality, and that's the hard part of singing. =)
@GrimReaper I wouldn't really call what I said feedback per say, considering it was more of a reactionary comment stemming from my history of habitually listening to legendary voices like Sinatra, Simon & Garfunkel, or Billy Joel. I of course can't realistically expect this magnitude of vocal skill (or recording quality for that matter). As for some actual constructive criticism, I feel like the track could use some remixing/ levels fixing, but I think you're probably already doing that based on the apparently unfinished status of the song on youtube. The actual vocals are reasonable, with the notable exception of the held notes being shaky/ off key from time to time. Overall I feel like you can probably improve it just by doing it again, which you're already doing so, good luck
@Versilaryan A strong sense of perfectionism and working off of previously mentioned standards like Joel or Sinatra make practicing singing a pretty painful process for me, but I try XD
21 comments:
First
FIRST!
@Travis Smith DAMN YOU!
6th!
HAH, don't feel bad, it's my first time
@Dethonator
This is sixth
I like the 3rd one. It seems off, though. If it was better synced up I'd like it more.
Still love the Pony Polkas
months later and we still have ponies posting "first" everytime... Oh well, everypony needs a little attention :D
I kinda-sorta know the guy who made the second one :D
1st is favorite because I've been looping that for the past 2 hours...
@Nimbus Buster
I just wanted to say I did it at least once on here, I usually like to be at least sixth because it's my lucky number.
@PrincessLuna
Tell them they made a great PMV
Patrick: "WE SHOULD TAKE THE BRONY ARTISTS/ AND PUSH THEM INTO VOCALIST CLASSES" but no, these guy's put a lot of effort into their work and that stands for a lot. Also they do it out of the love of a community/ tv show that is totally awesome. They deserve ALL the props, but the audiophile within me still shudders from time to time x_x
@Shutterfly
If you didn't like my singing, you're free to tell me what I can improve upon. =P
@Versilaryan
I like your singing, you're completely in tune and your voice is much better than the songs I have heard that have dudes singing in them.
@Versilaryan When I wrote that comment I had only listened to the third song. Your song I then listened to and immediately downloaded. Your singing was pretty much flawless, though your mic quality/ recording location made it seem a bit lackluster. The singing itself was great though. Also I had just finished listening to some pretty bad brony singing before viewing this post. I myself could never sing anything like your song because I, much to my chagrin, have the vocal range of half an octave. I do play/ listen to a lot of music however, cause its awesome.
@Shutterfly
I appreciate your feedback on my singing (3rd song) and will try my best to be better,
@Shutterfly
Haha, that's what I get for recording in a practice room. xD Problems happen when there's no natural reverb whatsoever. Thanks so much for the comment, though!
I'm sure you could expand that range a ton if you worked on it. You seem to know what you're talking about as far as sound quality, and that's the hard part of singing. =)
@GrimReaper I wouldn't really call what I said feedback per say, considering it was more of a reactionary comment stemming from my history of habitually listening to legendary voices like Sinatra, Simon & Garfunkel, or Billy Joel. I of course can't realistically expect this magnitude of vocal skill (or recording quality for that matter). As for some actual constructive criticism, I feel like the track could use some remixing/ levels fixing, but I think you're probably already doing that based on the apparently unfinished status of the song on youtube. The actual vocals are reasonable, with the notable exception of the held notes being shaky/ off key from time to time. Overall I feel like you can probably improve it just by doing it again, which you're already doing so, good luck
@Versilaryan A strong sense of perfectionism and working off of previously mentioned standards like Joel or Sinatra make practicing singing a pretty painful process for me, but I try XD
1. Invading to our hearts content!
2. Peaceful, but very enjoyable.
3. I like the original song, and this is just as good.
ahem top picture loss of hat
im not a brony
but i play tf2 and a lost hat is very bad
Post a Comment