• Pony History of the Day: The Words of Faust

    One of the amazing things that quickly became apparent to the fandom during the early days was the openness of the staff itself, particularly creator Lauren Faust. Quite frequently she answered a number of questions about Equestria, her work, her interests, behind the scenes process of making the show and much more either on her deviantArt page, Twitter or interviews she once did with EqD, 4chan, Ponychan and others years ago.

    In her answers she revealed a lot of what she thought of certain events in the show, things that had been cut or changed, and giving detailed background on a number of subjects, clarifying some of the fandom's earliest questions mostly back between 2011-2013.

    Going through the archives of Equestria Daily the best I can, I have compiled a large list of answers Lauren has given over the years but if you know of some I have missed, please feel free to add them in the comments! These span several years and it's quite possible I missed some.

    This is going to be a long article as I copy interviews, pictures and more from various articles on EqD over the years so be prepared for a wild ride!

    Lastly, a big thanks to the Ponycon crowd at our EqD panel for helping us come up with this idea to spotlight Lauren's old answers.

    Lauren Addresses Pony Weight and Seaponies

    Cancelled Big Mac Idea


    Spike's Original Backstory

    (Click for full)

    Details on Nightmare Moon's Banishment

    Lauren on Pony Parents and Reproduction

    Cadance Was Not Originally An Alicorn

    Scootaloo is not Rainbow's Sister

    Wildife Learning Center Charity Questions and Answers

    For those that are confused, over the last few days, she has run a few 30 minute long events dedicated to answering questions for the Wildlife Learning Center Indiegogo.  People could donate 25 bucks for a season 1 or general production question to be answered.

    Q: Who came up with Big Macs Eyup and what are you most proud of from your contribution to MLP?

    A: I did. Proving a "girl show" could be enjoyed outside it's core audience.

    Q: Where did the concept of parasprites, and Pinkie’s music to lead them away, come from?

    A: It was inspired by The Pied Piper and Trouble with Tribbles.

    Q: I've heard rumors that Trixie was initially a male character in planning, what were the original plans for this Trixie character?

    A: Yes, Trixie was written as male in the premise. Hasbro requested a female character. Story was not changed at all.

    Q: What is a plot that never made it into production? (My name is on the contributor page.)

    A: The ponies meet a pony who was raised by deer and thinks he's a deer. AJ and RD argue over whether to tell him the truth! He found out on his own, and decided to stay with the deer who raised him.

    Q: more conceptual question, where do all the rainbow's go that leak from RD's house? Should she call a pegasus plumber?

    A: They dissipate into the atmosphere. Her house was designed before we conceived how rainbows are made. Would have done it different.

    Q: Does Luna still have Nightmare Moon in her? because when she transforms into Luna, the color of her coat and cutie mark switch

    A: NMM is the jealousy residing inside her that came forth. Perhaps it could be sparked again-- or jealousy in someone else.

    Q: In Cutie Mark Chronicles, why did AJ leave her family behind for Manehattan? She must have broken their hearts

    A: It was just wanderlust. She wanted to see the world beyond the farm.

    Q: Why did Pinkie Pie come to Ponyville? Do her parents know?

    A: I'm afraid I don't have a ready answer for that! But, if it were up to me, I'd say that though she loved her family, she was simply bored and wanted to go someplace where she could meet more people and have more fun. She didn't belong on a rock farm.

    Q: Any more backstory to AJ's parents? They aren't ever really mentioned as an entire part of her backstory.

    A: Don't know what the final canon will be, but they had passed away in my book. Never thought of how, though....

    Q: So, I heard Princess Cadence was on the drawing board during S1. What was your original plan with her?

    A: She was not thought up until Season 2. She was created in the story room for that episode. Want to ask a different question?

    Q: How much input did you have on the visual design of the show?

    A: A lot. I designed the main & major supporting cast. I hand picked the artists who designed the background style. and I reviewed and approved all artwork for season 1. I designed a lot of animals in S1 as well.

    Q: What would have happened if Princess Celestia never sent NMM in the moon? Would NMM have won?

    A: Yes. Celestia had no choice but to banish her sister or night would last forever. She did so with a heavy heart.

    Q: I asked earlier if Cheerilee was in the original plan for the show

    A: Not in the very first inception, but she was in the bible. Hasbro requested she be included, so I decided to make her the teacher of the Cutie Mark Crusaders.

    Q: In ep1, the NMM legend says 'the stars will aid in her escape' and we see 4 stars 'freeing' her. Was there some lore behind this?

    A: It was meant to sound like lore, but specifics were never figured out. It would be something fun to figure out. Are they other creatures that were banished? What did they do? Who banished them?

    Q: Not a specific question, but can you tell me something fun about Trixie that isn't known? Thanks!

    A: She also went to Celestia's School for Gifted Unicorns

    Q: What was the thinking behind giving Spike a crush on Rarity?

    A: When I was writing the scene in the pilot where Twilight met Rarity for the first time, I needed to get across the idea that Rarity was exceptionally beautiful. I came up with the crush at that point, and it stuck!

    Q: There's a rumor that u had some male character part of the mane6. Is this true and who would they be? 

    A: That is not true. The Mane 6 were always female.

    Q: My question is, when developing Manehatten, would the other boroughs have been included (Ie. Bronx, Queens etc)

    A: We didn't develop the city that far. If a story were to take place there and called for boroughs, we would have figured it out at that time. It seems like a good idea.

    Q: How does it feel to have the power to inspire others to make the world a better place?

    A: Pretty amazing and unbelievable.

    Q: You told me you had a name for Berry Punch when we talked @BronyCon. Care to share that name on record? =D 

    A: I called her Pinot Noir! My drink of choice while working on MLP. Got me through a lot of late nights.

    Q: "A Bird in the Hoof" Why did Fluttershy have Twilight's and Pinkie Pie's gala dress?

    A: Oooooh! Ok. I'm afraid the answer is boring. It saved the artists time to put pre-designed clothes in the closet. It was for practical, cost-saving purposes, not creative.

    Q: Where was Celestia when NMM appeared? Don't answer if you never thought of it beforehand. Don't wanna destroy anybody's theories.

    A: In my mind, they were still young and still lived in the same castle together--- perhaps with their parents. It was the ruined castle in the Everfree Forest that was featured in the premiere episode. Before she appeared in Ponyvile, NMM went to Canterlot to find Celestia and use magic to banish Celestia in the Sun. REVENGE!

    I imagined them with parents, yes. I wish I could've made a series just about Celestia and Luna's youth. Sigh...

    Q:  Were Celestia and Luna the only wielders of the Elements of Harmony? or did they have 4 others? What Elements did they represent?

    A: Yes. They discovered them. They each had 3, but I never thought about who got what. Once Celestia used them on her sister, she could not wield them anymore. She had to wait for Twi and friends to reignite them.

    Q:  I heard but saw no proof that Ditzy Doo was actually a different pony then our Derpy. Is this true? 

    A: Yes. Ditzy Doo was written into Winter Wrap Up before the Derpy phenomenon started. I kept the name in my back pocket in case we ever needed a ditzy character again. When the fans started becoming obsessed with a certain cross-eyed background pony, I thought she could be Ditzy, but then you all named her and I didn't want to step on that. There was just a name, but no design for Ditzy Doo.

    Q: Thanks for doing this! What was going on when Twilight was hatching Spike's egg and her magic went crazy? 

    A: Whoah! I didn't think anyone would ask! And just under the wire too! She had a power surge-- her first. She couldn't control it. Celestia sensed this HUGE magical ability, rushed over, and put a magical "cork" in it. She then decided to train Twilight personally, hoping she would one day learn (through friendship) how to control this magical power herself.

    Q2: So Celestia had an ulterior motive!

    A2: She knew Twilight would be the key to reigniting the elements.... and other stuff I planned that didn't come to be.

    Q: Why did Doctor Hooves have wings in episode 16? in season 1?

    A: Unless the directors had some plan I'm not aware of, it was just easier to slap a pair of wings on an already-designed earth pony than to design and build a brand new character. It was just to save time and money

    Q: Spike's age: teen, preteen, elementary age?

    A: I think of him as about 8 in maturity.

    Q: Were Diamond Tiara & Silver Spoon meant to be interchangeable bullies, or were they different (leader/follower, or..?)

    A: Meghan created those two, so she knows better. But I saw DT as the queen bee and SS as the follower. DT is slightly meaner and driven in my book. SS might have been nice if she made a different friend.

    Q: For an aspiring cartoonist like myself who's stuck in the Navy for a short bit

    A: The best advice I can give is to never stop drawing. Imagine you have 10,000 lousy drawings inside you that you have to get out before you're any good. Don't get discouraged, practice guarantees improvement. Keep learning. If you can't take classes, pick up art books or take online classes.

    Lauren Faust's Thoughts on Bat Ponies

    Lauren on Luna's New Look

    Lauren on Celestia, Twilight, and Spike's Relationship

    Lauren Faust Ponychan Q&A Compiled

    Q: I gotta ask, do you think you'll ever get to chat without it turning into a Q&A?

    A: I dunno. I guess we'll see, right?

    Q: So what's up?

    A: Not much. I worked late tonight. Glad to be home. What's going on around here?

    Q:You said you intended for Twilight to eventually replace Celestia. Does that mean you intended for Celestia to eventually die/be otherwise written off?

    A: I think it's best for me to keep what my plans were to myself. It would be unfair to the current showrunners and their plans. Maybe someday, though.

    Q: what can we look forward to for your current and future projects?
    Also, do you think you'll be able to implement the plans you had for MLP into some other incarnation? Thinly veiled suggestion, I know.

    A: I will be working on developing a few projects at once over the next several months. Nothing is concrete yet.
    And I've thought about it.

    Q: Animated movies like Wall-E and Wreck-it Ralph have gained mainstream acceptance as something that can be enjoyed by anyone, not just children. When, if ever, do you think cartoons will reach the same status?

    A: We have to wait until the folks with the money are willing to give something like that a try, and for audiences to be open to the idea. Over the years, Craig and I have met more and more parents who enjoy some of our shows with their kids. I think as the newer generations have kids, we may see it happen more. Hope so.

    Q: Lauren, I've been dying to know, what was your ultimate plan for scootaloo? Also is she really an orphan? In case you didn't notice, she's my fav

    A: I can't say I ever Scootaloo as an orphan. However, I did not have specific plans for what her family deal was. If in the process of making the show it came to define, we would have done it then. Somethings you plan from the start, some things you come up with as you go.

    Q: Do you watch the shows you work on, or does being so involved in the whole development process kinda burn them out for you?

    A: I do watch the episodes I worked on. However, having worked on them from the beginning definitely warps your ability to view them. I don't think you ever see them the same way viewers do.

    Q: Did you have plans for the cmc's eventual cutie marks, or was that open ended?

    A: I had plans for Scoots and Belle, but I was still working out Apple Bloom's.

    Q: You've mentioned you had a lot of ideas for your characters that you never got to see through. Whatever those plans were, did you talk to Jayson or Meghan about what they were so that, if they chose, they could still use those plans?
    For example, you mentioned in one interview that Zecora would've been like a second mentor in Twilight, and she wound up playing that role in one of the recent episodes.

    A: I may have said a few things. I can't remember who I told what. Zecora as mentor was actually in the bible.

    Q: If a unicorn can become an alicorn, can a pegasus or earth pony become one too?

    A: In my book, yes.

    Q: Actually, I'm curious. Are you finding that producers and the like are getting more open to major/lead female characters in animated material given the success of MLP, Littlest Pet Shop, and Legend of Korra?

    A: Absolutely not. Despite it's popularity, MLP doesn't get great ratings--- not compared to bigger networks, anyway.

    Q: Was Equestria Girls in the plans when you were still working on the show?

    A: Nope.

    Q: What does being a princess in Equestria actually mean?

    A: For me it meant having certain responsibilities in terms of running the country--- just like it does in real life. Not sure what it means currently.

    Q: I'm not a Pony Channer by habit, I'm mainly here because I missed your visit to 4chan, that said It is nice to have the opportunity, on a thread on 4chan there is a debate on how much of the Royal Wedding was your work vs what was changed, if you have answered this many times before I apologise, I know that the third Alicorn was definitely not in the plan, but that's about all I can see for sure given the overall strength of the episode

    A: I ran the story room and broke the story with Rob and Meghan. I didn't see the final episode, so outside of the name and pony-type change for Cadence, I don't know what was altered.

    Q: Anyways I just was curious to know if your aloud to answer, which tv show company did you like working for more? Cartoon Network with the Power Puff Girls? or The Hub with Ponies. Was there big differences between the two stations?

    A: I must admit I enjoyed Cartoon Network more. They had more resources, a lot of experience behind them, and I was working at the studio directly with the crew, which was more fun than working remotely from my home office, which got lonely.

    Q: Lauren, In reference to all the controversial things that have happened...could we have prevented this? Do we as fans have some culpability in what has become of our beloved ponies?

    A: I don't think so.

    Q: Lauren, I loved the letters to Celestia, especially when they became a major plot point of the second season's opening in restoring Twilight's faith in her friends using her own words. Were you guys directed to include the letters by the network? Why were they eventually phased out as season 2 went on?

    A: When developing the show, I was asked to have some sort of defining "friendship device" in each show. Someone initially suggested some sort of "move," which I thought was kind of terrible. One of the execs and I worked out the Mork and Mindy style letter at the end to define the friendship lesson. I think it worked out well. By Season 2, the Hub said we didn't have to keep doing them, but I liked them and kept them up in Season 2 (did they ever stop them?) They just became so definitive of the show to me, it felt weird to let them go. I think I would've kept them going indefinitely.

    Q: Mrs. Faust, did you have any plans for more including creatures from different cultures of the world, were there and could there be more of them in the future, and could we possibly see more in the future?
    Also did you come up with the idea of Tartarus existing in the Ponyverse?

    A: Yes, I was planning/hoping for more creatures and more cultures---- I wanted Viking Caribou!!!!! I'm not entirely sure who came up with Tartarus in the story meeting room, but I do think it was me. Seems like my kind of gag.

    Q: Ok, I have a question for Faust on behalf of /mlp/
    Did you ever made any sketch or character concept of A.J, Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy's parents, or they were just meant to stay offscreen?
    We often ponder what could have been in contrast of what actually happened.

    A: I did want AJ's parents to have passed away, but I never defined it (when I was running it) because I didn't think they would allow it. I was holding out to see if those restrictions would change. I had hoped to make RD's mom G1 Firefly. I never did sketch any of the parents, and only had vague ideas of who they were or what they did. For details like that I would usually wait until a story warranted a definition, then define it according to the needs of the story. Rarity's parents, for example, where never planned until we needed then for the episode. Neither were Pinkie Pie's

    Q: Did you have any characters you wanted to introduce and the voices behind them ala DeLancie and Discord? Perhaps Starswirl the Bearded as another Star Trek alumni?

    A: I never, ever, ever assume I can cast a celebrity. Many don't want to slum in cartoons unless it's for a place like Disney, and even then it can be a long shot. Getting John was a shocker to me.

    Q: Really? Celebrities have a stigma against doing cartoon voice overs?

    A: Yes! We approached a few for SBFF and they all said no!!!

    Q: Was it your idea to have Twilight's mom me G1 Twilight? Because that was amazing.

    A: Yes. Though I wish the colors were even more accurate. I felt to nerdy to call the note.

    Q: Ms. Faust, if I may, why is it that the pigs and goats seem to lack sentience?
    Was this not your idea or just something that slipped through the cracks?

    A: I would've made goats sentient, but not pigs. (only ungulates and ruminants)

    Q: I've got a question concerning Luna/Nightmare Moon. In the show, we're not told what (if any) evil force may have affected Luna to make her evil. I wanted to ask, was Luna's turn to evil her own decision alone, or was it influenced by some evil force that hasn't been (and might never be) revealed?

    A: Aaaaah--- can't answer that. I'd be giving away too much of what I had planned.

    Q: What was the hardest part about working on the show when you were working on it?

    A: Schedule. It was horrendous.

    Q: Lauren, was it your idea to have the shot for shot remake of the Star Wars scene in the season 2 opener? Because that may have been my favorite part.

    A: No. The directors and the story artist planned it. I died laughing when they showed it to me.

    Q: Do you feel that shows and toys directed at young girls have recently gotten better, worse, or not changed?

    A: I think toys are getting worse and worse. I've seen some shows that at least seem to be trying. I don't see a lot that I like, unfortunately.

    Q: Did you want to add any new pony type to the show?

    A: I had an idea for seaponies. Wasn't sure about it though.

    Q: Do you know what was Craig's inspiration to create the PPG episode 'Meet the Beat Alls'? You know, the Beatles tribute episode.
    Why did he decide to create an episode dedicated to them? Is he (or you) a fan of Beatles?

    A: We are both HEE-YUGE Beatles fans.

    Q: Do you watch Doctor Who?

    A: No. And I am ashamed. Where do I even start?!?

    Q: Lauren, without getting into the details of your departure from the show, is there any possibility of reconciliation and your return to the creative team in some capacity if both parties could come to an understanding? Or are those bridges burned and everything behind you by now?

    A: I have had a hard time of letting go of MLP, but I really think I have to move on. I hope some of the themes I wanted to explore can be brought into future projects. I think I can do more of what I'd like to if I wasn't restricted to such a very young audience. Making something for kids over 10 would be more satisfying.

    Q: So Lauren, why don't you update your DA gallery? Surely, you must have things worth sharing with the world.

    A: I never have time to draw!!! It's the great tragedy of my life! And when I do, it's for work and I'm not allowed to share it!

    Q: It would be nice if you could share your show bible and your original ideas with the people working on the comics.
    They're not strictly canonical, but if I'm entirely honest I'm enjoying them way more than the show after you left.

    A: I think that bible might be the best thing I've ever done. I'm insanely proud of it. I'd love to share it, but it's not mine to share. Maybe someday.

    Q: Lauren if you had the chance, would you build your own high fantasy television show with no pre-established brand placed on it? You and the team did a great job with building a universe in FiM using greek and roman mythology but I wonder if you'd be willing to do something like this without the small crutch of an already established ruleset.

    A: Believe it or not, restrictions like that are actually helpful. When you have a blank slate, and the possibilities are endless, you get overwhelmed quick and it hard to creatively commit to ideas. If you have source material, it's more about finding connections and filling in blanks. I actually enjoy it. 
    Not that I wouldn't do something original. The challenge could be fun if I had the right support

    Q: Did you have any help creating the bible, or was it all you? Any tips you could share for helping other creative designers with their own settings?

    A: I had help from Paul Rudish (wait until you see his Mickey Mouse shorts- OH. EM. JEE.) And bg designer Dave Dunnett and colorist Martin Ansolobehere.

    Q: did he work on that old style short that is coming out "get on your horse" i think it is called? the one using old Walt Disney recordings.

    A: WATCH IT NOW!!!!! http://video.disney.com/watch/disneychannel-croissant-de-triomphe-4d7b3aae690a98650d776d97

    Q: Hey Faust, as an animation fan from /co/ I love how MLP revealed the double standard regarding girl and boy shows to (some) of the world.
    Do you have any idea how to repeat that? What would be for you the perfect "girl" show that'd attract everyone?

    A: I think it's just about writing great stories and avoiding the restrictions of normal girl fare---- stuff for girls is either dumbed-down, goody-two-shoes-y and terribly art directed. There is a way to portray girls and their interests in a truly entertaining way, and as long as people aren't afraid of cooties, there's no reason everyone can't enjoy great stories, no matter what the themes.

    Lauren Faust Visits 4chan to Answer Questions

    Q: How have the characters deviated from your original vision? More specifically, since you left?

    A: The characters evolved a bit from the original bible descriptions--- but that happens on all shows. Writers, board artist, voice actors help define the characters further and you go with the flow. Some personalities might have been a bit more exaggeratted--- I wanted RD to have an irresponsible streak, and I wanted Rarity to have a more "don't touch my stuff" relationship with Sweetie Belle. More so than is in there, but I was not unhappy with where they ended up. I haven't seen the recent episodes, so I can't judge any changes made

    Q: Hows Craig been doin

    A: Great! Having fun on the new show.

    Q:  How would you have ended S3?

    A: I would have used it to lay groundwork for my plans for the characters' ultimate destinies and the series finale

    Q:  How goes the work with Mane6?

    A: Good, but slow (because of me and stupid schedule.) Hopefully, we should have some stuff to share in a few weeks.

    Q: Can you explain how Galaxy Girls would have worked? Because that cast looked way too big to really work well for television.

    A: Galaxy Girls was designed to be a doll line. I actually never wanted it to be a show, but the folks who make toys want shows before the invest. Despite the surprising success of MLP, most companies still want the same old garbage for girls because that's what they think make money (and they don't want to spend much to make it). If I have to make it a show, I'm not going to make it until I can make it good--- so it may not get made.

    Additional question to above:  

    Q: What would the show (Galaxy Girls) be like, if it ever gets made?
    Epic adventures in space, or slice of life comedy, or something different?

    A: Thematically, I was planning on making it a lot like MLP--- slice of life + fun adventure--- just in a fantasy, story-book version of space. But I put a lot of those ideas and themes and characterizations in MLP. If I move forward with it at this point, I would like to completely redesign the characters. I kind of hate the way they look right now. I drew that stuff almost 10 years ago.

    Q:  I too, wish to know what Lauren Faust thinks of the comics

    A: I haven't read them, but from what I gather, they are exploring some interesting themes.

    Q:  Why didn't Hasbro just request a Galaxy Girls show to sell something to compete with Monster High? Were they high or something?

    A: No large company wants something they can't own and control completely.
    Q: I think we all need to know. Who is best pony?

    A: You are going to hate this answer, but I can't pick. It's like asking a Mom to pick her favorite child.

    Q: Who do you like better? Supergirl? Batgirl? or Wonder Girl?

    A: I enjoy writing Supergirl the best. I love getting the chance to write hot headed characters.

    Q: Faust, is there anything you would recommend to someone who is about to do their first big animation project?
    My capstone for college has to have 8 animators and a minimum 16 crew total, and I'm kinda running short on what and where exactly I should be looking for everything. Like, is there anything specific I should look for in an animator's reel, aside from just strong and fluid work?
    I'm the school's "test student" to see if they'll start doing an animation program, and a lot rides on whether or not I succeed, and any advice you might have would be more than valuable.

    A: Strong and fluid work--- but also you need to gauge whether they are a good creative fit for your project. Someone can be amazing, but a bad fit. Unless they're very versatile--- those artists are gems!!! Look for people who can work reliably, and artists who can take the lead when you have too much on your plate.

    Q: What's your favorite episode of PPG? I've always wanted to know

    A: Rowdy Ruff Boys!!

    Q:  Lauren, since you gave some life advice to someone else - I've been wanting to break into the animation or art-for-television type of field, but my background is in graphic design. I live in the Midwest and I'm in my mid-twenties and I feel like I'm in a rut - not qualified with nothing nearby to push me where I want to go. What should I do? Do I need to move? Take classes? How do you do it?

    A: Being in the right place makes a big difference, if you can afford the move. Otherwise, classes, and try to get animation work online, where your location doesn't matter. Once you develop good relationships, you'll get more work and it will be easier to move to where you can get even more work

    Q:  Can you post some sketches of what you'd like? That would be really neat to see

    A: I have some sketches I did several months ago I've been thinking of posting on DA. I'll do it next week when I get home (I'm traveling)

    Q: I think I remember you telling someone on DA that you originally planned to have the main six have different body types/styles but were either short on time or money. If you had any specific ones already in mind could you describe what each pony would have looked like had been able to spend more time designing them? Also, great to see you here again!

    A: It's not that we were short on time and money, it's that I anticipated it would be a production nightmare to make them all different. I tried to get as much of their individuality into their hair and eye shape as I could.

    Q: So what's the deal with the Princesses? Did you ever plan on going in to more detail with their history?

    A: I didn't plan on it, but I was hoping I could

    Q: Lauren, Seriously, I love you. Stay safe in here, it can get freaky at times, but we all mean well in the end.

    A: I know. :)

    Q: Why did you choose to come here (4chan)? It's not like we have the best "fame" in the fandom. I'm just curious...

    A:  I've said it before, but I've seen some of the most thoughtful critiques here. I need to dig through some awful stuff to find it, but people are smart here sometimes.

    (Daww, you guys are loved.)   

    Q: Lauren are you going to any conventions this year?

    A: I think I'll be at Comic Con--- not sure yet

    Q: Lauren, what was your biggest influence on Rarity?

    A: Audrey Hepburn

    Q: Yo Lauren Faust, "Luna Eclipsed" and the midsection of "Hearth's Warming Eve" in Season 2 really feel like your work (and more like Season 1) than the other eps in that season. Am I right? Also, which episodes of Season 2 did you work on the most (stories, mostly)?

    A: Wow. I can't believe you noticed. 

    I worked on all the stories, structurally, and only did script work on the first half. Luna Eclipsed, HWE are two I had a heavier hand in-- also Lesson Zero. Can't remember which others.

    Q: How was working on Cats Don't Dance?

    A:  AMAZING! I was 21, non-jaded and in love with my first job!

    Lauren Faust Interview for Equestria Daily

    1. Hello, Lauren. Thank you very much for agreeing to this interview and for taking the time to talk with Equestria Daily. Let's begin then. First, let's discuss the steps that led to the creation of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic. When and how did you first cross paths with the My Little Pony franchise?

    When I was 6, I saw the first large and brown “My Pretty Pony” toy in the store.  I was a typical horse-obsessed little girl already, but I liked tall, graceful thoroughbreds and Arabians, so the pudgy pony wasn’t quite as interesting to me. But when they came out with the multi-colored ones, I couldn’t help but reconsider. They were too darn cute and I just I had to have the Pretty Parlor with Peachy, my first little pony. Then, when Hasbro came out with the unicorns and pegasi, there was no going back.  Horses and fantasy? I kissed Strawberry Shortcake and Barbie goodbye, and soon, I was spending every penny I was given or earned on collecting every pony thing that came out.

    2. Did Hasbro contact you regarding a leading role in their new Friendship is Magic reboot of My Little Pony, or did you approach them? What did they present in their case to you?

    I had approached Hasbro to pitch a micro-series pop opera for my Milky Way and the Galaxy Girls project, and it prompted Lisa Licht from Hasbro to ask me if I’d be interested in My Little Pony. She handed me one of the recent DVDs (Princess Promenade) and asked me to watch it to see if there was “anything you could do with it.” They wanted a reboot, and she was really pushing to match the right talent with the right project. Hasbro was just coming off the success of the Michael Bay’s first Transformers movie and Lisa was interested in finding similar “creative stewards” - talent that would re-invent and lend their unique voice to their other properties. The possibility of this sort of creative trust and freedom and Lisa’s belief in this approach really piqued my interest.

    3. Following up on that, why did you decide to spearhead the show? What factors secured your interest and confidence in the high quality and wider appeal of Friendship is Magic?

    At first, it was just because it was fun and easy.  I had played with the toys for most of my childhood, and I literally referenced the characterizations and stories I made up for myself when I was little.  The characters you see in the show were based entirely on the personalities I gave certain toys.  Many of the locations where expansions of the MLP playsets I played with in the '80s. I used to say that my own inner eight-year-old was my personal focus group.

    And beyond that, my confidence in the project grew as the more work I turned into Hasbro, the more they said “yes!”  Developing animation for TV is often (though not always) a grueling and disappointing process, and you can end up miles away from your vision.  I’ve known people who’ve directed their own pilots while no longer knowing what they were trying to say or who their characters were after having it developed to death.  I didn’t want to be in that position. I was also so passionate about making quality entertainment for girls, and I didn’t want to be responsible for adding to the pile of entertainment garbage that’s so often targeted toward them.  I was always waiting for things on MLP to take this sort of bad turn during the development process, but they never, ever did.  Hasbro was kind of awesome that way.

    4. So, you signed on as developer and creative director of MLP:FiM - but even you couldn't do it alone! You needed a team of talented, dedicated, and creative individuals to surround you and bring this universe to life. What measure of independence did Hasbro afford you in choosing those professionals - producers, writers, artists, animators, voice actresses, composers, and so on - that would end up working with you toward the goal of creating this fantastic cartoon? Any particular people with whom you were able to reunite from previous work on Powerpuff Girls and Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends? Any particular people you were able to bring on board with whom you'd always wanted to collaborate?

    The development of this show and the greenlight to pre-production were just about exactly one whole year apart.  While developing the concept for the show, I personally produced a 40+ page “pitch bible.”  I was hired to do this on my own, so I was free to hire the help I wanted with the budget I was given.  I hired two artists to help me with this early phase.  Martin Ansolobehere, with whom I had worked on Powerpuff Girls and Foster’s Home for Imaginary Friends, did some adorable initial background concepts for this bible.  And my friend Paul Rudish, a key creative for shows like Dexter’s Laboratory, Powerpuff Girls, Samurai Jack, the first Clone Wars and Symbionic Titan, assisted me with conceptualization and art development.  In particular, I remember an amazing sketch he did of pegasi romping across clouds to make it rain.  This inspired me to come up with the concept of the ponies controlling the weather and otherwise being stewards of their world.  He also came up with the initial version of Nightmare Moon.  Paul is a creative powerhouse, and I felt very fortunate to work with him.   This version of the bible consisted of art by Martin, Paul and myself, and I did all the writing.

    A little after the bible was first presented, I was asked to do some more visual development, and I hired Dave Dunnet and Lynne Naylor.  Dave’s first background designs (colored by Martin) all made it into the show and became the defining reference point for the art direction. Lynne designed the final Nightmare Moon and Luna.  And of course, my husband Craig McCracken listens to me gripe, pontificate and bounce around ideas about whatever I’m working on, so his influence is spread throughout.

    Once the bible was finalized, with main and side character designs and descriptions, locations, and general world dynamics, Hasbro then started interviewing several production studios. DHX (then Studio B) was one of them. I was impressed by the animation in Martha Speaks (they made Flash look like traditional, and their animators were adept at animating four legged animals), and I was impressed with the energy, humor and overall direction in Pucca. So, when Studio B pitched that they wanted Jayson Thiessen to be the supervising director, I felt very confident that they could do what I was looking for.  Together, Jayson, Wootie (James Wooton) and I made a two-minute short to demonstrate what the show could look and feel like - and sometime later, Hasbro secured Studio B to produce the series.

    Once the show was greenlit, I was able to hand-pick my writing team (with Hasbro and Hub’s approval), most of whom I'd worked with on Powerpuff or Foster’s.  The rest of the artistic team was put together by Studio B and Jayson.  Jayson endorsed Ridd Sorenson as art director, and I approved him.   Voice actors and composers were all auditioned, Jayson and I endorsed our picks and Hasbro and the Hub made the final calls.  There were only a couple picks we disagreed on, but obviously, it all worked out great.

    5. In the pre-production planning process, who brought about most of the decisions regarding the format and layout of the show (2D Flash animation in 22-minute episodes)? During this critical stage, how much of the show's conception was due to the team at DHX Media, and what specific requests did Hasbro issue regarding their franchise and content?

    I pushed for Flash and Hasbro trusted me.  I wanted 22 minute episodes, but briefly the plan was for 11s.  Ticket Master was actually the very first script and was written before the show was greenlit, and it was originally 11 minutes.  Hasbro changed its mind eventually - I can’t remember why. I was glad. I prefer 22s. 

    By the time pre-production began, I had the concepts for the show already nailed down in my finalized bible. I had finished development, which included the characters, their personalities and designs, main locations, tone, several premises and three scripts - I had them all ready to go.

    Once we were greenlit, the Studio B team was brought on and it was less about developing and more about MAKING the episodes. I went up to Vancouver to meet with the team and give out initial direction. Ridd and his designers then started expanding on the art direction and Jayson and Wootie started building the astounding Flash builds for the main characters while starting storyboards.  While they were doing that, Rob Renzetti and I started the script process with our writing team in LA.  Hasbro was pretty amazing at trusting us, which was fortunate because we were going so fast.  The only changes that Hasbro made at that time were visual tweaks to locations that had playset potential and changes to some of the names of locations and side characters to make them more “salable."

    6. Excitement must have been building as the show's ideas finally began to coalesce! What were the primary challenges in this phase? Any particular innovations or epiphanies strike the crew as the show transitioned from planning to the first stages of execution?

    For me, the primary challenges were 1) The schedule - literally twice as fast as any production I had worked on before - and 2) being separated from my crew. I was in LA working alone from my home office, while everyone (except the writing team) was in another country. In these crucial beginning stages, ideally you want to work very, very closely with your artists from day to day to keep the vision cohesive - no one can see what’s in your head, and with so many artists, you can get a lot of different styles, ideas and approaches.  It’s up to the showrunner to pull it all together...and it’s really hard to do over the phone and email, and to do it twice as fast as you’re used to.  I felt so fortunate to have Jayson and Ridd in Vancouver.  It would have surely been a huge mess without their expertise to guide the team to achieve what I was looking for.  All the work, when done, was sent to me via the Internet for notes, revisions, and final approval.  There were times I would have liked to have just walked down the hall and talk to an artist about revisions, but I had to do it all via email, which took longer and lacked the luxury of back-and-forth.  There was a lot of trial and error to work through in the beginning, and I ended up doing a lot of designing and storyboarding myself because I couldn’t just tell people what I wanted to see.

    Another challenge was meeting the perceived needs of our young target demographic.  We had to figure out how to make the more adventure-y shows compelling and exciting without being scary.  It took some extra thought and a combination of careful storytelling, lots of jokes, and appropriate, appealing designs.  Tone adjustments helped as well - like lightening a scary situation with humor and whimsical design, or making an otherwise non-threatening scene more tense with art direction, music, and proper timing.

    Similarly, there was also worry about seeming mean - and I don’t mean cruel or dastardly, I mean slightly rude or mildly insulting.  We had EI (Educational and Informational) standards to adhere to, and character behavior that was considered OK in shows I’d worked on previously was suddenly considered “inappropriate for children” in My Little Pony.  Something as mild as Rainbow Dash calling Twilight an “egghead” in Fall Weather Friends was treading a very delicate line.  Even the whole concept of her and Applejack cheating was worrisome to some.  It was tough to find humor and create character conflict within these very constricting boundaries.

    The biggest innovation, I feel, is the animation.  Jayson and Wootie delivered far beyond my expectations and have done things with Flash I thought was completely impossible.  I used to put notes on storyboards that said “revise staging, this is impossible in Flash” and they’d write me back all “no, we can do it…” and they did.  Also, I feel the art direction was an interesting innovation in that most shows aimed at girls are overly bright, garish, oversaturated and plagued with waaaaaaay too much pink.  I think the colorists achieved something that is definitely feminine, but unique in that it is still extremely appealing, pleasant, and devoid of cooties, if you know what I mean. ;)

    7. Tell us about some of the major contributors at this point and throughout the show's run. Jayson Thiessen was the supervising director for Season 1 and has succeeded you as showrunner for Season 2. As supervising director, what was his primary responsibility, and how did the chain of production run from Hasbro through you to Jayson and the other leaders?

    Rob Renzetti was a big contributor, and, of course, Ridd, Jayson and Wootie. Rob and I handled all of the story development and scripts down in Los Angeles.  Once they were done and approved by Hasbro and The Hub, we’d get them recorded, and hand them off to Jayson and Wootie to begin the production work.  Jayson would supervise his team in Vancouver and send me the work at each phase (design, color, storyboard, animatic, animation rough cut) for direction and/or revisions and then make sure my revisions were put in place.  Each of these phases would then go to Hasbro and The Hub for any further adjustments.

    8. Rob Renzetti has contributed to many cartoons over the past two decades - including 2 Stupid Dogs, Dexter's Laboratory, and his own My Life as a Teenage Robot. How did you collaborate with him in his role as story editor, and how did that writing process flow between top decision-makers (such as you and the folks at The Hub) and the actual writers and Rob?

    I was so thrilled when we got Rob on the show!  He’s extremely talented, and having run his own show in the past, very experienced and knowledgeable.  Rob and I came up with and wrote all of the story premises.  Once approved, Rob and I decided who to assign each script to and spent a whole day with the writer, just the three of us, planning the story of each episode together.  The writers started writing, Rob and I gave notes and sometimes did revisions at each phase (outline, first draft, second draft). Then the outlines and scripts went to Hasbro and The Hub for notes, further revisions and final approval.  If the notes from Hasbro and The Hub were light, usually Rob handled the revisions himself. Once approved, the recorded scripts were sent to Studio B for the next phase of production.

    9. Sarah Wall is the producer of Friendship and Magic and other DHX Media productions. What roles did she and the other DHX leaders play in the creation of Friendship is Magic? Similarly, what aspects of the show's first season drew chiefly from crew suggestions?

    Sarah manages the day to day production, budget, and schedules; and she and the production staff made sure the artists got the material they needed when they needed it.  I’m amazed at the work producers do; it’s so much to juggle.

    As for crew suggestions, we occasionally held “writers’ summits” in LA (though I wish we had had more) to brainstorm new premises.  In the writers’ room, many of the script writers came up with and defined new characters. There were also many board artists and designers in Canada that had a certain way of drawing expressions or body language or hairstyles or outfits that further defined the way the characters looked and acted. These were constantly compiled and referenced as production went on. 

    10. Ridd Sorensen is the show's art director. What elements of the show's design drew from your initial sketches, from Ridd's direction, and from Hasbro's specifications? How much did the design and style of the first season change from initial conception to final production?

    The initial BG design treatment from the show came from Dave Dunnet.  We were fortunate to be able to bring him on for the two-part pilot to design many of the main locations and the ruins in the Everfree Forest.  I designed all the main and supporting ponies and Spike, and they were not changed from the bible.  Beyond the pilot, Ridd and his team developed the style even further under my supervision.  I continued to do a lot of the character designs in the beginning.  All in all, I don’t feel the art direction really changed all that much after development, it just continued to evolve and get more refined. 

    Hasbro’s input came mostly when a location had potential to be a playset.  Rarity’s Carousel Boutique was revised a few times.  There were also times when they were working on a toy they wanted to have featured in the show.  The hot air balloon was introduced this way. Often they’d ask for a location beforehand, like a schoolhouse, so we could design it first.  They were pretty great about letting us decide how to use these locations in context of the story so it didn’t just seem to come out of nowhere.

    11. Daniel Ingram and Will Anderson compose the wonderful songs and music found in abundance throughout MLP:FiM. Could you describe how you and the rest of the team coordinated cues, goals, and ideas with Daniel and Will? What transpired between the producers, writers, and Daniel to bring the ponies' songs to such vivid life? Similarly, how did you and the top decision-makers work together with Will to infuse such lush music into FiM?

    Whether or not a story warranted a song was decided in the story meeting.  In the writers’ room, Rob, the writer, and I would plan what information needed to be communicated in each song and discuss what sort of tone the number should be.  Then it was up to the individual writers to compose their own lyrics for the songs in their scripts.  Once the lyrics were approved (usually along with the whole script), Daniel came in. I would give him some brief direction at the start - then he’d come back with an initial recording (usually with a temp singer). He would sometimes make small adjustments to lyrics to suit the music better.  I don’t recall giving him many notes that were beyond tweaks, except for when we had to ask him to make the Cutie Mark Crusader theme song WORSE - poor Daniel!  But it was an essential story point that their performance was legitimately bad. Once all was approved, he produced the final records.

    Will and the score came later.  Once the animation rough cut was done with the final timing and editing, I would meet Will at his studio (he is also in LA), and Jayson or Wootie would call  in through Skype.  The three of us would review the episode and “spot” the episode - directing Will on what kind of cues we want to hear and when.  It was a very collaborative process. 

    12. Friendship is Magic is a labor of love brought about by hundreds of devoted individuals, and we fans truly appreciate the efforts and handiwork of each and every person who has done any sort of work on both the show itself as well as its exemplary wellspring of promotion at The Hub. As such, we do not want to exclude anyone from our outpouring of thanks and genuine support. However, in the interest of highlighting crew teams and processes that might otherwise go largely unnoticed, could you expound upon any facet of the show's creation and production that benefited Friendship is Magic beyond the readily obvious results?

    At any given time, a designer would design a side character in a direction I hadn’t thought of, or a board artist or an animator would add a gag or a character trait that would help define the show further.  Also, the voice actors bring so much to the characters that you would never imagine without them.  It’s an ongoing, organic process - and everyone involved contributes to the evolution of the world.  As with any show, it was a very collaborative effort.

    13. Thank you very much for all of your insight thus far. If you don't mind, Lauren, I'd like to transition from discussing the show's conception and structure to exploring the timeline of the first season itself. First of all, in your estimation, how long was the time period from conception to production and from production to debut? How many episodes was your team managing at one time, and why did you and DHX stagger and juggle them the way you did?

    One 22 minute episode took almost a year from conception to completion.  A final show usually aired about a month after it was delivered.  There was an agonizing point in the schedule where we were literally working on all 26 episodes of season 1 at one time - and, once Season 2 was greenlit, we’d even be working on as many as 32 at once. 

    Staggering episodes is, as always, the standard production process. You have to stagger the episodes to make sure everyone is working.  For instance, when a character designer is done with episode 12, we can’t fire them and hope they’re still available when episode 13 is ready.  Episode 13 needs to be ready for design right away, which means the script needs to be done, and script 14 needs to be ready just one week later.  It’s very much run like an assembly line.  A new episode had to begin every single week to keep the process running, so everyone on the team had work.  It’s especially trying on those of us who are supervising all aspects of the show.  On any given week I was coming up with a premise, calling notes on an outline, calling notes on a first draft, revising a final draft, revising designs, recording and episode, revising a storyboard, calling notes on an animatic, spotting music, reviewing and calling notes on music, and finally delivering the final episode.  And each of these steps was for a completely different episode.  On most productions, this is actually a 2 week process, but we had to make it work as a 1 week process. I’ve never worked on a schedule so fast.

    14. What were some of the greatest triumphs you experienced during those precious first stages of actual production? Likewise, what were some of the most difficult obstacles to overcome? Which elements turned out unexpectedly better or worse than initially estimated?

    There was skepticism and concern about the art direction in the opening sequence of the pilot.  Some people thought that having the series begin with such a different look would turn viewers off.  I love the look and feel of that sequence.  I was so glad to keep it. 

    The characterizations of Pinkie Pie and Rainbow Dash were a worry to some as well.  It was thought that Rainbow was too boyish and our target audience wouldn’t relate to her, and it was also thought that Pinkie Pie would be irritating and off-putting. There was even a lot of debate and concern over Applejack’s accent.  I spent a lot of time trying to reassure everyone that they would be lovable characters.  In the case of Pinkie, once everyone was finally comfortable that she wasn’t annoying, we got to make her as zany as I had always envisioned her as the season went on. It’s a testament to Hasbro that they put their faith in us as they did.
    What came out better than expected, as I mentioned before, was the animation.  It turned out far better than I had ever dreamed.  When the first walk and run cycles were sent to me for approval, I fell out of my chair.  And Daniel Ingram’s songs were grander than I ever imagined.  The voice actors made authentic stars out of the characters.  Tabitha St. Germain, for example, added a humor to Rarity that was unexpected and wonderful.

    It’s hard to point to anything coming out worse, at least not in the beginning.  The first few episodes were a little wonky here and there, but that’s to be expected.  It always takes a few episodes for a crew to hit their stride.  Any disappointments I have at that stage are only in specific details - certain character designs that I didn’t love, some jokes that fell flat, etc., but nothing consistent enough to be worth mentioning.

    15. The season began with a two-part introduction to Equestria, unfolding the tale of Twilight Sparkle's journey to Ponyville and her triumph over Nightmare Moon with the help of her newfound friends and the virtues represented in the Elements of Harmony. Afterward, the season continued to hold a certain level of continuity but meandered from story to story as a episodic romp. Why'd the approach change, and how did this impact production and creative input? What do you believe emerged as the strongest component of the new direction; alternately, what do you believe you could have accomplished had the show stayed on its first course?

    This is a good opportunity to clear up a bit of a rumor. Something I said on my dA page turned into an interesting Internet game of telephone; consequently, a lot of fans now seem to think that I had a grand scheme for a big, dramatic, serialized magical-girl style of a show. Actually, it was always my intention to have the show partially “adventure stories” and partially “relationship stories,” as I called them in my initial pitch bible.  I had thought that maybe a third of the episodes could be more like Dragonshy, or the end of Feeling Pinkie Keen, or even have this creepy thread through them like Stare Master. But, ultimately, fewer than a quarter of the episodes had this adventure aspect to it. There were several reasons why. For example, restrictions on what was considered too scary for our younger demographic put limitations of the types of stories we could tell.  The accelerated schedule also made it difficult - plot heavy episodes take too long to plan, and too many new characters and locations were a heavy burden to the crew at such a fast pace.  If we had tried to do more, they would have fallen short; and since we had a cast and crew that was so well versed at comedy, it just seemed like the right decision to de-emphasize that style. 

    I don’t think the consequences of this minor change in direction were really felt in Season 1 except for the quantity of the types of stories.  The tone or humor would not have been different, and the expectation that we could start going in that direction in later seasons gave me hope that I could still fulfill some of the characters' grander destinies; but, truly, I always wanted this show to be an ensemble-cast comedy first and foremost. 

    If we had penned more adventure stories, the only difference I can think of is that perhaps you would have seen more of Luna and Zecora.  Zecora was designed to be a sage and mentor to whom the ponies could go for information about their quests.  She was designed to be a second mentor to Twilight, but that didn’t come to pass. And Luna, though good, was meant to be associated with darkness and night - and these are considered (by some) to be iffy themes for a show for young girls - so she had to slide to the wayside.

    16. Thanks for clearing that up! Here's hoping it dispels some of the idle gossip about the intro arc. Now, at the heart of the show are its well-designed and endearing characters - indeed, the show has differed slightly from previous incarnations by choosing to focus on chronicling the escapades and developing the personalities of six main ponies (plus Spike!). How did the team's ambitions drive the construction of the main cast and their excellent compositions: fantastical yet relatable, strong yet flawed, caring yet selfish, appealing yet imperfect?

    I doubt any team of writers sits down and strategizes whether or not to have good characters or lousy characters.  Everyone wants good characters - just, not everyone can execute it.  We had a great team who could.  Not to toot my own horn, but the foundations of the characters were the chief focus of my pitch bible.  I literally wrote the characters with their “good traits” and “bad traits” described in their introduction.  The writers took these ideas and ran with them in the scripts, the actors with their voices, and the story artists and animators with their expressions and posing.  I kept tight watch, especially in the beginning, to make sure all this input was cohesive, pushing and prodding when needed.  For instance, I encouraged people to keep the wacky gags exclusive to Pinkie.  I cleared some of the initial confusion about how to make Fluttershy and Twilight funny, and Rarity needed special care to keep her from being the typical shallow debutante character.  I created these characters, and I felt the need to protect them.

    17. Your body of work demonstrates a zeal for character-driven media. What have you seen in your career that compels you to champion and create this style of media, and why do you pursue your specific dreams and aspirations? In short, what does Lauren Faust hope to achieve - and leave behind?

    I champion character-driven stories and humor because character-driven stuff is just what I like to watch and what I like to do.  I think making your audience experience an emotional reaction is the core of good storytelling, and you can’t evoke emotion without likable, relatable characters. Some shows focus on gags and written jokes and have an exclusive goal to get laughs, but I prefer comedy that has a sincere emotional core...and humor that comes from characters, not one-liners. Somehow, it’s just a bit of a strength I have.

    My specific dreams are still to make great entertainment for girls. I just don’t think there’s enough truly good stuff out there for them, but I also have kind of selfish reasons.  When I think of something I want to say or an experience I want to share, my ideas are usually innately feminine because I’m female - and I refuse to believe that something being feminine by nature automatically means it isn’t worthwhile.  If I can put the tiniest dent in the perception that “girly” equals “lame” or “for girls” equals “crappy,” I’ll be very satisfied.

    18. The ponies are definitely the heart of the show, yet they occupy a world that is rich with mythology and fantasy while still sporting a variety of modern technology. What was the creative strategy behind constructing the realm of FiM's Equestria? How did the team approach this balance between mythological fantasy and modern tech?

    I always wanted the default technology of the show to be a bit medieval in nature; but since this is a whimsical, non-serious show, I felt there was plenty of wiggle room.  I think ultimately it was just my personal comfort level in each individual story.  If it screwed up the story to get too technical about how primitive the technology was, it wasn’t worth it. So, if we needed cameras, I just wanted those cameras to be relatively workable to a creature with no fingers.  And if we absolutely positively HAD to have an electrical appliance (which we often did), I just told myself that it was enchanted by some magical unicorn mechanic at some point.  However, I insisted that such an attitude was to be considered only as a last creative resort - don’t use a light switch when you could use a candle, just because you’re feeling lazy.  Don’t draw a hoof unnaturally and awkwardly wrapped around an umbrella because you don’t feel like thinking about it a little more. Overall, though, it was definitely not a strict approach - and it’s hardly consistent.  Humor and ease of storytelling took precedence over technicality.

    19. Seems to me that a lot of foresight went into the creative planning process. Apart from the new episodic direction, how often did long-term plans change during the course of the first season, and what were the primary reasons for any major shifting?

    There was a lot of planning in development and a lot of planning for the animation process in the beginning - but really, at a certain point, once production was in full swing, we were kind of flying by the seat of our pants and making it up as we went along.  We had to rush to get stories approved and into production.  I actually regret that there wasn’t more time for planning and fine-tuning.

    20. Wow. All of that must certainly have been taxing - but I can assure you that the end result has been unquestionably worth it! What were the most rewarding aspects of creating the first season, and why were they so fulfilling?

    For me, it was amazing to see all these ideas I'd had for years and years about how to make compelling stories for girls come together.  So much of what is in MLP is what I’ve been trying to get on the air since I started in TV.  It was amazing to see it actually work and people actually like it.

    21. I imagine that level of success elicited quite a large volume of feedback. Were any particular strengths or concerns frequently mentioned in letters and other responses you received?

    By far the most common message I received was “I’m a guy and I love this show - what have you done to me?!” ;) I’ve received a lot of notes from men in the military who are fans of the show.  That’s been a wonderful surprise!  I’ve also received many messages from people who say the show has helped them through depression, which is truly touching.  And I really love when I get letters from dads who say it’s their favorite thing to share with their daughters. Another favorite, common note is from young female artists who say the show has inspired them to write their own stories or pursue a career in animation.

    22. Describe how the various media reports impacted your direction and outlook, if you would. At first, several outlets were noticeably caustic, owing either to insufficient information or simple misunderstandings. More recently, the level of positive coverage from the media has been trending sharply upward. What do you make of all the articles - both positive and negative - and why do you suppose that the general perception has changed, beyond simply increased exposure to the show?

    When I accepted the job in the first place, I expected that the usual “ew gross, girls!” response was inevitable.  I even expected that people would actively hate it without even watching it.  So, when the first uninformed, unjustifiably negative articles surfaced, I was disappointed, of course - but not surprised.  I just thought of the girls who’d finally have a worthwhile cartoon to watch and tried not to worry about the folks we weren’t targeting.  I knew (or at least I thought I knew) we wouldn’t sway their biases no matter how great the show was.

    23. You did well in that! Of course, any discussion of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic would be shortsightedly incomplete without targeting the most incredible online phenomenon of 2011: Bronies! I'm a brony, Lauren - as are scores of thousands of other teenaged and adult fans of MLP:FiM. First off, how and when did you and the team first learn of the brony phenomenon? How closely did you end up following it as the first season progressed?

    Oh gee - I feel old to admit I did not know about 4chan until I was checking comments on an episode that had been put on YouTube.  Someone pointed out that people were freaking out about the show on 4chan, so I moseyed on over and WOW - was I surprised!  I checked in regularly (strategically ignoring unsavory material as best I could) and pointed it out to some other members of the crew.  Then came Equestria Daily and Ponychan.  I couldn’t believe how the fandom was spreading - or the amazing creativity that was coming out of it!  It was just such a FASCINATING turn of events, and I was simply riveted.

    24. What aspects of this brony phenomenon took you by surprise? How did it impact the direction of the show and morale of the crew? What were the most encouraging aspects of this newfound fanbase - conversely, what logistical difficulties accompanied our advent?

    Just how it kept growing and growing and growing and how it seemed to inspire a revolution of kindness on the Internet!  It never ceases to amaze me.  I think the surprising fanbase invigorated the crew and kept us going when we were getting exhausted.  There’s no better morale booster than making an actual impact.  I can’t say it affected the direction of the show beyond crossing Derpy’s eyes, however.  All of Season 1 and the opener for Season 2 were written and underway in production by the time the brony phenomenon took hold.  We couldn’t change anything at that point.

    25. The Hub television network has earnestly been reaching out to us in the recent months. What's your take on primary vs. peripheral demographics? How did you seek to unify the two, and what do you expect will be the standard moving forward? Put succinctly, how do bronies affect ponies - in our purchases, discussions, fan works, and the rest?

    While we were moving forward on Season 2, we all felt that we attracted this audience with the strategy we laid out to attract girls and their parents - so we didn’t think there was a need to change the approach, at least as far as the show is concerned.  If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it, right?  However, even outside of bronies, I was hoping that some of the “nicey-nice” restrictions would be lifted for Season 2 or that we’d at least get more wiggle room. Not because I had a need for edginess, but because I thought we were going to start running out of ideas to explore within those restrictions.

    26. Thanks for all of your answers so far, Lauren. We truly appreciate your candor and willing communication with us. As this Q&A draws to a close, could we touch upon a few lighter topics before we conclude? First of all, the four EqD blogponies - Sethisto, Cereal Velocity, Phoe, and myself - are all extremely grateful that you agreed to this interview. How closely do you follow Equestria Daily and other major pony fan sites?

    I will admit I still check in on EqD almost every day, and I checked Ponychan when episodes premiered to get feedback.  I consider them very valuable resources - and, frankly, fun!  I also admit I’ve occasionally contributed to discussions, and I’ve even dropped a few spoilers for fun - yay for anonymity!  I totally lurk, guys...so careful what you say!  ;)

    27. Wow, thanks much! (And how clever of you!) How about the rest of the fanbase - fan art, music, videos, and the like? You and several other FiM crew members have been very active on sites such as deviantArt and Facebook. This high level of communication and interaction with the fanbase has been unfailingly valuable, and we most certainly appreciate it! How often are you able to keep up with all of the pony fan output - and would you like to say a few words to those who create it?

    Not to disappoint, but I’m afraid I don’t read fan fiction - I just don’t have time, and I don’t want the accidental influence.  But I love looking at fanart, fan comics, custom toys, and the YouTube mashups.  There is some talent out there that completely floors me.

    28. Thank you so much, Lauren - believe me, we all sincerely appreciate your support! Now, once again, new horizons are spreading before you - horizons as yet unknown to the rest of us. As much as you can, without giving anything specific away, could you tell us what we can expect from Lauren Faust in the months and years to come? What's the next move for you, and how - and, more importantly, why - are you blazing that trail? How have ponies shaped your philosophy and outlook moving forward, and what do you expect will be your single most poignant and lasting memory from your time as the watchful shepherdess of the pony herd?

    I have a lot of irons in the fire right now, and I’m waiting to see which one shows the most promise.  It is still difficult to sell animation for and/or about girls, but MLP gives me something to point to as a successful example.  People didn’t even believe girls’ shows could be legitimately funny and that boys might actually watch them...yet, between Powerpuff Girls and FiM, there’s proof that lightning can struck more than once.

    The most lasting effect working on this show will have for me is the literal 'dream-come-true' facet of the opportunity.  Not only was it a chance to bring one the most inspirational aspects of my childhood to life in the manner I had dreamed it could be since I played with ponies as a child, but it was also a chance to put my theories about entertainment for girls into practice.  Seeing it work so well that it brought in an additional, unexpected audience was a triumphant bonus.  However, what will also stick with me is the sadness I felt when I realized I had to leave it. It was a horrible, painful decision. It still stings...and I suspect it always will.

    29. We'll definitely miss you moving forward, Lauren. Thank you for all you've done so far. How do you expect Friendship is Magic to end when it inevitably (and unfortunately) does? What do you foresee taking place in the final episode? More personally, how would you like to see the show end when it inevitably (and unfortunately!) does? What would constitute your ideal final episode?

    Not to give a disappointing answer, but - as I won’t be involved, I don’t know how to expect the show to end.  I had my own ideas for an end to work towards, with certain characters fulfilling specific destinies. Only some of those plans were well-formed, though; others, I had hoped to work out as the series progressed. I’d rather not share what my plans were at this time - it will diminish what the new people in charge ultimately do. Plus, it just really bums me out that I can’t do them.

    30. Stepping back and viewing the larger picture, how do you perceive this show has shaken the stereotype of a young girls' show? Friendship is Magic is certainly a constructive step toward portraying that media in an intelligent and positive light, but a large stigma nevertheless persists. In your estimation, what's the next step - and what else must be done before that detrimental stereotype can begin to fade into irrelevancy?

    I think the show may have opened the minds of a number of specific individuals, but I don’t think its influence is really far reaching enough to make that big an impact - yet. I’ll be curious to see how the attitudes of the young girls and boys who enjoy the show grow as they do. Perhaps having enjoyed the show will make them less resistant to similar content as they grow older, and perhaps it will inspire them to create similar things.

    Next steps are just to continue in this direction.  Networks and studios need to be willing to give feminine concepts a try, the people who can make this kind of stuff need to be given more chances, and audiences need to put their preconceived notions aside and give female content a try.  They need to somehow let go of the idea that liking something feminine is belittling. I think that last one is the tallest order of them all.

    31. How do people such as bronies factor into this situation? What distinctions between a "boys/guys" show, a "girls/gals" show, and a "family" show should and should not exist, to you? Why do the current distinctions exist, in your mind, and how can people such as the teenaged and adult MLP:FiM fans influence executive and marketing mindsets toward these programs? At the root of it all, is the "divide" between the genders dwindling ever smaller - and what will it take for males and females to be equal as humans?

    I love the idea of “all ages” entertainment - media that is enjoyable to male and female, young and adult.  But the perception currently out there is that, if the main character is a girl, or if a significant portion of the cast is female, it is “for girls” only and exclusively.  And usually, if something is planned for both genders, it means most of the characters are boys - and that maybe, if you’re lucky, there are a couple of girls who get to tag along.  I long for the day that female characters are not considered novel.

    At the same time, it’s hard to ignore the evidence that some specific content will attract mostly women and girls and that other content will mostly attract men and boys.  I think that’s okay too - not to mention fun.  The problem is the positively ancient issue that a girl will watch a show or a movie about a boy - but a boy won’t watch a show or movie about a girl.  The people who profit from media need to protect their investment, and they know they’ll get a larger audience and make more money if they default to “for boys.”  It remains the most common reason why girl stuff isn’t made.

    The only thing that will change this is support.  The audience supplies the ratings and the profits, and that’s what the money people are looking for.  If you like a show involving girls, watch it and buy the stuff.  Spread the word, refuse to be ashamed, ask for what you want, and visibly support artists who do it well.  All of this encourages the people with the money to give this kind of content a chance.

    As you said, the divide between the genders may be dwindling...but the gap, in my opinion, is still large. If you look around you, people still insult boys by comparing them to girls (“pick up the pace, ladies!”) and praise girls by comparing them to boys (“wow, you draw as good as a guy!” - to quote what someone once said to me when I was a student). The question of what it will take for everyone to consider the genders equal is way too big a question for me. I have no idea. But I think it’s up to everyone as an individual to carefully and honestly evaluate their own attitudes and at least try to make things better - if only in their own lives and the way they treat people they know.

    32. Thank you so very much for taking time to answer all of these questions, Lauren - and for spearheading the magical cartoon that is My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic. We love it, and we love you too. To you and the rest of the FiM crew: Thank you all  - so immeasurably much. This concludes the Equestria Daily Season 1 retrospective interview with Lauren Faust. On behalf of everypony, I wish you the absolute best. If you've any final thoughts or comments, Lauren, please share them with us.

    Just a great, big, extremely sincere thank you to everyone who watches the show!  This kind of fan reaction is the sort of thing every artist dreams of but doesn’t dare believe can actually happen.  I always worried that, despite the late nights and work-filled weekends - the blood, sweat, and tears (well...not blood) that went into the making of this show - it would go almost unnoticed, as many shows do.  You guys make it all worthwhile, and I can’t thank you all enough.

    Twitter: Calpain