Thursday, January 5, 2012

Poll Results: Best Pony Psychological Breakdown?

Looks like Twilight Sparkle losing her mind is the most popular breakdown! I have to admit, Lesson Zero has been my favorite episode ever since it aired.  Sonic Rainboom nukes, Fluttershy going wuju-style on a bear, and Rarity's overly dramatic attitude really showed off what this team is capable of when they go all out on a comedy style episode. 

But I digress!

This is a little late, so we already have a poll up.  Feel free to ask for new ones in the comments though, I'll find a fun one for after BroNYCon. 

83 comments:

ombutescentdin said...

Ah yes Twi is best brakdown.

ftfc said...

Minute Late Seth.

RavensDagger said...

Pinkamena would like to have a word with Twilight.

Bombedrumbum said...

"Fluttershy going wuju style" Woah. FlutterRage was pretty funny.



Twilight FTW

Travis Smith said...

No surprise really
Next poll idea

Best animal ever shown
1. Dragon
2. Hydra
3. Manticore
4. Windego
5. Ursa Minor

ScootalooIsBestPony said...

Have a poll asking who the best Trixie is. I feel as though the results could be quite shocking...

Bombedrumbum said...

@Travis Smith

That was already done.

Poll: Best non-pony character

Bombedrumbum said...

*creature/species/whatever

naahdude said...

If this doesn't show how much this fanbase has grown since S2, I don't know what does. Pinkie had this shit man. HAD IT.

CityFlyer502 said...

Lesson Zero was where it all started for me. I think I would have become a brony anyway, but I think Twilight's deranged antics during that episode made it happen that much quicker. Granted, I didn't get a look at it until a few weeks after it aired, but once I saw it, there was no avoiding the inevitable.

ombutescentdin said...

Oh, polls you so controversial.

ftfc said...

@Travis Smith
Wendigo.



Best Blog Pony!

Architraz Warden said...

Aww, man... I thought 'Flutterage' was the apex of her night at the gala. If I'd known, I'd have voted for something else.

Travis Smith said...

@bombe
Really? Shoot...

Which is Seth's favorite!
1. Trixie
2. Sparkler
3. Lyra/Heartstrings
4. Derpy
5. Other

archiveit said...

Lesson Zero is probably in my top 3 favorite episodes, but the classic breakdown has still got to be Pinkamena.

Bombedrumbum said...

I'd just like to say that for the current poll, I voted Earth pony. The description was amazing, and speaking of Lesson Zero, it showed what the tanks- I mean Earth Pobies are capable of. Cough Big Macintosh's Big Boom cough cough

GraffyHooves said...

Hmm yes an opinion poll on what people think Trixie is. Canon and a showboat that hates the world or just misunderstood but I'm not sure it would make a good poll @scootalooisbestpony btw

joetraincool said...

Speaking of polls, how are earth ponies failing so miserably in the new poll? Sure, Unicorns have magic, and pegasi have the ability to fly, but earth ponies have TECHNOLOGY *cue epic music, fireworks, etc*. And fewer limbs to break. But I digress.

ThemsAllTook said...

I'm honestly surprised Pinkie didn't win this one.

Select Few said...

Poll Idea: Best Pony Tumblr

Ask /THE/ Prince Blueblood
Ask Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy
Ask Pinkamena Diane Pie
Woonastuck
Ask My Little Chubbies

That's all of the ones I can think of at the moment. I'm sure that there are other awesome ones that I'm not aware of, though.

Haze said...

I still went with Pinkamena, it still scares me a little to think what would happen if Pinkie loses her mind again, but that may be due to Cupcakes.. yeah.

Senior Waffles said...

Fluttershy's breakdown causes lightning, that's pretty sweet. But I suppose Twilight's is rather amusing and Pinkie's is pretty sad. I don't think Rarity's and Applejack's count though. Rarity just overreacts (as always, but that's why we love her), Applejack's was just part of her normal personality.

the invincible said...

I just wanted to say again how awesome I think it is that you guys used my idea for this poll. I also wanted to say I'm not surprised at the results. It was pretty epic and hilarious seing Twilight lose her mind in that episode. But allow me to try and change some minds out there for those of you who are undecided. Here's a list of things you can't do:
1. Watch this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gyQIO0LcsJs
2. Tell me you don't wanna give her a hug right now.
Can't do it, right?

Sanguinity said...

Dunno if it's been done yet, but here's one I thought of.

What's your favorite part of the fandom?

A. The bronies
B. Music
C. Art
D. The show it'self
E. Fanfic
F. Spreading love and tolerance
G. Other

CityFlyer502 said...

@archiveit I will concede that Pinkie's breakdown was funny. Nothing says crazy like a party with dust bunnies and such. But there's something about Twilight progressively going bonkers that beats Pinkamena any day. I mean, she got the whole town to go nuts over the Smarty Pants doll. All because she was so desperate for report material. Just my thoughts, which are not necessarily correct. LOL

RubberDuckie said...

Y U NO CHOOSE PINKEMINA

Octavia said...

I voted for psycho Twilight myself. She was simply too hilarious in the episode not to vote for her.

As for the current new poll... poor Earth ponies are trailing so far behind.

Nickvicious said...

@Travis_Smith More like

Which is Seth's favorite?
1. Trixie
2. Trixie
3. Trixie
4. Trixie
5. Trixie

ponydoraprancypants said...

@Select Few

Don't forget "Ask Surprise" as a top 10 tumblr.

Bombedrumbum said...

I think that Discord should have been in this poll. Seeing as he is the god of chaos and all

CityFlyer502 said...

@Nickvicious Uh...can I use a lifeline?

herpyderpy said...

I voted for Pinkamena, party of one was awesome :x

wackypony said...

Rarity's 'worst. possible. thing' got plain annoying by the third time. Twice was pushing it.

AlexReffand said...

Twilight Psycho wins, as she should

Scribbles said...

Lol, wuju style. You been playing with Master Yi, Seth?

(Best LoL character. Maybe not for strategy, but definitely most fun.)

Jimperator said...

The ammount of crazy faces alone made her breakdown the best. But then you add the subtle gesturs like her ear twitching and her teeth grinding, etc. It was just so absurd and comical that it ensured Twilight's spot as my second fav pony.

AH said...

I've got one,

If you were to burst out in Pony song, which one would you sing?

-"A Circle of Friends"
-"Winter Wrap Up"
-"Pinkie's Singing Telegram"
-"Art of the Dress"
-"No Fear"
-"Find a Pet"
-"At the Gala"
-"Giggle at the Ghosties"
-"Hush Now Quiet Now"
-"Becoming Popular"
-"Equestria Girls"
-"Evil Enchantress"
-"Making Cupcakes"
-"The Theme Song"
-"You Gotta Share, You Gotta Care"
-"The Cutie Mark Crusaders Theme"
-"A Hop Skip and a Jump"
-"So Many Wonders"
-"The Pony Pokey"

(insert or edit song names as needed :) )

Tylendal said...

Sorry, but I don't think it's Wuju style unless she's using a weapon.

Tylendal said...

Also, Sethisto has been playing too much LoL.

Kaijyuu said...

I found the entirety of Lesson Zero (except the end) to be full of narm. It was painful.


I voted Pinkie because she actually retained my sympathy during her breakdown. Much more depth to that episode.

palaminopegasus said...

Which episode had the crazy cat rarity episode?

Applejack said...

Have you ever had a 'Who is the best pet?' poll?
Of course between Winona, Tank, Gummy, etc.

Cedric Bale said...

1 + 26 + 47 + 17 + 3 + 3 + 0 = 97%

I demand a recount.

Cedric Bale said...

@palaminopegasus
It was the episode with Art of the Dress.

the invincible said...

@ palaminopegasus
Ah, that would be Suited for Success. A greated episode on its own, if I may say. And that was why Rarity got my vote. Nobody breaks down like a moviestar; just ask Charlie Sheen. And who else is so good at breakdowns, that they always have a fainting couch within magical grabbing distance?

CityFlyer502 said...

@AH I'm all for this one. Though I haven't been in this long enough that there's one song I would suddenly start singing. My sister would go for "Giggle At The Ghosties," even though she skips entire verses.

Travis Smith said...

I've got a lovely bunch of coconuts

Jebediah Oldenheimer said...

Twilight Sparkle's mental breakdowns are just as great as she is.

Jebediah Oldenheimer said...

@Cedric Bale
Well, you have to acknowledge the decimal percentages that don't get shown. There's probably .9s and .5s across all of the results, which would up the sum to the full 100%.

God I hate math. But it's so burned into my skull I'll always be the first to solve equations.

TheCastro82 said...

I was expecting Pinkamena. lol
Also, the next poll should be "Best Filly".

CityFlyer502 said...

@Travis Smith NOOOOOO! Curse you! I'm gonna have that song stuck in my head for the rest of my night!

The Numberman said...

Twilight's breakdown was hilarious. Lesson Zero is one of my favourite episodes from both seasons.

Why aren't earth ponies getting more love?

wackypony said...

@CityFlyer502

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=bAYbv19_Wv4#t=7s


HUZZAH!!

Mr.Anonymous said...

While your favourite episode is Lesson Zero, Seth, for me it's the worst episode ever and even worse than Cutie Pox or Luna Eclipsed because of how over the top and shallow the characters were.

Michael Butcher said...

I still think Pinkie's breakdown was the most frightening thing I've seen in a children's show in a long, long time

A Bard said...

@Mr.Anonymous

What's wrong with Luna Eclipsed?

Drüd said...

new poll:
What's your favorite type of pony art?

-animation
-comic
-fanfics
-3D/gmod
-vector
-traditional style
-PMV
-I don't look at/like pony art
-other
(not sure if this has already been done)

thehansenman said...

PsychoTwi scares me...

Harwick said...

I'm still pushing for "The Hub wants an FIM spin-off... Which pony is chosen to anchor the new show?"

CityFlyer502 said...

@wackypony OK, maybe I'm not that freaked out. Tell me you'll strap me to a chair and make me watch the Direct TV help channel on loop, and then I'll be freaking out.

Jimperator said...

Sanity is overrated.

Harwick said...

I loved Psycho Twilight so much, and just like Pinkie's breakdown I think it made the character that much more endearing. There's something charmingly tragic about the lengths that she pushes herself to meet expectations and how spectacularly it can all come collapsing down upon her when she fails. She's a pony who puts insane amounts of pressure on herself... that it was such a seemingly little thing that broke her seems so apt. Especially when you consider it was her own organizational skills that failed her by forgetting she had a lesson due, and not anything that was entirely out of her control.

I also think it had the most important Friendship lesson of this season, and perhaps of the show itself... Notice when someone you know is having trouble coping with a situation, and don't let it escalate into tragedy before you're moved to reach out and help. There aren't too many shows that can tackle a subject that includes everything from suicide to school shootings that subtly.

archiveit said...

@Harwick Applejack. She's my least favorite of the mane 6, but I actually think she would be well suited for something like that.

Ten said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Ten said...

I found this a tough one to choose between PsychoTwi and Pinkamena.
But it all came down to dat face

FreezingShock said...

I voted for InsecureDash. That episode really made it incredibly easy for me to relate to her.

Eeveexpert said...

*Digs out hipster glasses*

I haven't been in the majority vote since the "Best Stallion" poll. Personal preference pushed me to vote for Flutterage here. In my opinion, that was a better break of character than Twilight's was. I always took Twilight's ridiculously organized personality to be the kind that could easily snap like what we saw.

Of course, this is not to say that I didn't like Lesson Zero. I've loved every episode of Season 2 thus far.

'S just my two bits.

Harwick said...

@archiveit
I'm a fan of Applejack myself, but I see where you're coming from. She's a bit too much like Twilight as a (normally) stable character rather than a zany supporting one. It's easier for her to play the straight man (mare) in any group/comedy dynamic.

I think the toughest thing about spinning off a show with Applejack as the lead is that, out of all of the cast, she seems the one most anchored to the current setting and style of the show. Other ponies you could move to a new location, but after her Cutie Mark story how do you make Applejack leave the farm?

Not that I'd personally object to simply more of the same from a spin-off, but usually they go for some kind of new setting or set-up.

Tokyo Oranges said...

Hiiiii Bronies *twitch*

PsyTwi is best Twi ;D

Scherzando said...

Fluttershy: YOU SKEELS ARE EENFERIOR!

Eddmario said...

I think the next poll should be what fanfic should be adapted into a full-length feature film.

Ulrik said...

I voted for stubbornjack

Aelthar said...

Master Fluttershy, The Wuju Bladespony

Ulrik said...

Applejack is the best pony.

I think we will see Applejack's breakdown in The Last Roundup.

James Corck said...

Psycho Twilight is best Twilight.

I like many other episodes of Season 2 thus far, but Lesson Zero is the most entertaining. That mental breakdown was way too much fun for nobody to really enjoy.

Nameless said...

Meh, Pinkie's had more depth. Twilight's was just a parade of funny faces.

WhitFox said...

Had to go with Twilight because it entertained for a whole episode. Flutterrage was fantastic, particularly the diabolic laugh, and Pinkamena was cute too. But watching either for 15 minutes would have been sad, rather than funny.

Love the song poll idea, but we might want to limit the list to the shorter ones. I think we already know Winter Wrap-Up and At the Gala are hits.

AppleDash said...

@Sanguinity
What's your favorite part of the fandom?

Duh All of it silly :D

bored0stiff said...

Twilight going mental was pretty hilarious, but I chose Pinkie's breakdown - because that episode made me a brony.

b0b4_f3tt_043 said...

As if the way TS snapped in s1 ep10 wasn't bad enough already...

Lesson Zero was a rather bizarre experience for me, having to watch the character I most identify with becoming deranged. It certainly didn't help that I myself was stuck on an assignment when the episode was released. 0_o

Nonetheless, the absurd nature of Twilight's mental breakdown had me laughing like a mad man. (Damn, I'm mean.) Naturally, I had to go with PsychoTwilight on this one. Lesson Zero FTW

Lizzy Pie said...

Next poll

Best Grimdark fanfic... :)

Post a Comment