Saturday, December 3, 2011

Story: Why Didn't Ah Stay At Th' Farm? (Update Part 2!)


[Comedy] [Shipping]


Author: FanNotANerd
Description: A...minor accident at Sweet Apple Acres sends Big Macintosh to Ponyville in the middle of applebuck season. At first, things seem fine. But then some of the mares begin acting a little...oddly. Then very oddly. Turns out every other stallion skipped town for a very good reason.
Why Didn't Ah Stay At Th' Farm? (New Part 2!)

Additional Tags: Parody, Funny, Minor Innuendo, Aggressive Fluttershy, Big Macintosh

Live Readin

79 comments:

Bombedrumbum said...

Sounds like a quality humor fic!!

EvenMotion said...

Aw man, read that at FiM fiction. It was pretty funny!

Travis Smith said...

I need a good laugh now

Viridian said...

Haven't read yet, but just from the cover image I'm loving it and chuckling. Derpy's inverted-heart eye just sealed it for me.

CityFlyer502 said...

I have gotta take a look at this one.

Travis Smith said...

Side note
The war of naming the new mare is still raging, be sur to vote for Lady Wolfinshire the lll, for more info check out the Drawfriend

DoctorBrony said...

Hey, my Dramatic Reading made it in there! :D

Celestia said...

I had a laugh at the idea, Poor Big Mac just doesn't know what's going on.

Hivemind said...

Bow chika wow wow :3

Celestia said...

I must also add Derpy's upside down heart is adorable.

DoctorBrony said...

@DoctorBrony If only my link was a little bigger... :3

Viridian said...

*finishes reading*

I'll see if I can't make a more informed reply once I quit laughing, but for now...

HILARIOUS. XD

Travis Smith said...

I like the way this story's going but please for the love of all the world hasn't taken grime me, no gay Dash shipping please.

WizardShy said...

That was hilarious.

Val Yuni said...

This one had me col'ing.

MedicShy said...

Okay, that was hilarious. Worth a read, but i refuse to think any of this cannon... or about any after effects. Not in my ponies, darn it!

Edwin B. said...

This brought alot of lolz to me, I just cant imagine if I was able to go to Equestria that this would happen.

Raph0n said...

Applejack planned it all!

Traxus said...

This...was...hilarious

Ceci said...

Lol. I feel incredibly bad for Big Mac.

Shoggoth said...

So this story ends with forced rape? Think twice about what you put up ED.

ryan said...

I was about to read this on FiMfiction. Now I know it's good. Thanks, Seth.

Mr. Unsmiley said...

It's about time this made it on the site! This story is hilarious, and I can't wait for the next chapter!

Mr. Unsmiley said...

@Shoggoth
Haven't you learned yet? Forced rape is always funny if it's female on male.

Shadow Heart said...

It came out today, and we already have a pic. Good work bronies.

Bombedrumbum said...

Wooh, that was quite a fic. 'specially the ending

Travis Smith said...

@Travis Smith
*from, not grime.

Ragneki5880 said...

Do I hear corny pick up lines coming from the respective mares towards Big Mac? No? Here's hoping. . .

Aidinthel said...

@Shoggoth
I'm pretty sure rape is by definition forced. And yeah, what Mr. Unsmiley said. There's a TvTropes article on it.

Weim_Time said...

THIS IS HILARIOUS KEEP MAKING MOAR!!!!!!!!

crris14 said...

I saw this fanfic yesterday but wanted to read it later until this came up...you win this round equestia daily

Nimbleware said...

i have a good feeling about this one

LilBlkPony said...

*sees aggressive fluttershy* oh boy this will be interesting

Marcus 'Badger' Birchill said...

Damn, beat me to it. Ah well, mine was rubbish anyway, and I lost it when my USB glitched.

K4RN4GE said...

Minor innuendo? MINOR innuendo?? There was nothing minor about that whole story! That was PG-13, NSFW I just read!

Regardless, I laughed. Alot. I know it's not canon, but I wouldn't be surprised if that's why we don't see many males. They're scared out of their minds of it being that "time of the year."

Oh, almost forgot, obligatory RvB Bow Chica Bow Wow from the one and only Tucker!

Pyro Brony said...

That was hilarious. I'll agree with Big Mac when he says Mares are crazy. Fluttershy especially.

TheOutcastsofIre said...

I could not keep from laughing. Try as I might, fanfics like these always make me laugh, no matter how hard I try to keep it in.

Tundra said...

@Celestia
I was half expecting you to show up in the end.
But...
*shivers* the thought of Molluna is just flat-out frightening.

Aesoporific said...

Dude got sold out by his own sister. That's cold.

BlackBlood15532 said...

Additional Tags: aggressive fluttershy

......*thinking*

Dosko said...

Oh man, near the end there I was sure Molestia would make her appearance.

Seriously funny stuff.

Chris said...

Personally, I found the ending to be in terrible taste. I'll concede that mine appears to be the minority opinion, but I can't find any humor in the idea of someone being repeatedly, aggressively raped, regardless of the respective genders of the victim and the rapist.

As a concept, I did think that "every mare in Ponyville goes into heat simultaneously" had comic potential, but the way the story concluded just killed it for me. In light of my mixed feelings about the story I'll refrain from rating it, but I felt that this could have been a very funny fic had it gone another direction.

DPV111 said...

It was amusing as a comedy fic and the gags were funny.

I really REALLY don't like the concept of Ponies going into heat.
Although the way you wrote it seems like a period of heightened libido rather than an exclusive period of sexual availability. So not SO bad.

If every mare in Equestria including the Princesses go into heat simultaneously, what is the point of the males leaving town? There's nowhere to go.

Also... ALL the males ran off? They fled to avoid an orgy? Um... not so believable...

Also Bic Macintosh was all "I don't want a relationship."
I'm pretty sure none of those mares were looking for one...

3 Stars for humor, premise was weak.

DPV111 said...

Oh an AJ SO set him up.

cheezesauce said...

@DPV111
i agree. Some parts of the story didn't make sense. it sounded as if it was a hastily written piece of work.

But the humor was good, and that's what im reading this for.

RGamer2009 said...

This is already the funniest fanfic I have ever read.

Iron Brony said...

To the writer: I hope you continue this! I really liked it.

Aleril said...

I couldn't get into it. The premise of all of the mares going into heat at the same time is just so silly, plus the fact that they do the same old routine with Dash's sexuality.

To me, it feels like it's written like a clopfic without anything cloppy.

Aleril said...

I couldn't get into it. The premise of all of the mares going into heat at the same time is just so silly, plus the fact that they do the same old routine with Dash's sexuality.

To me, it feels like it's written like a clopfic without anything cloppy.

Photon said...

If i was him id say "ah who cares" and go with. Fluttershy would be all i need

Bryan said...

@Chris

Ah, good, I wasn't the only one who found the combination of Big MacIntosh getting raped and the [Comedy] tag a bit incongruous.

I can actually find it plausible that the mares of Ponyville could synchronize their estrus, it's not unknown in the animal kingdom. But that's a side issue, really.

AlexReffand said...

@Chris You don't think rape is funny? Picture Porky Pig raping Elmer Fudd, THEN tell me rape isn't funny.

Ergo Cogito said...

I could say a lot about this, but I'll stick with "I lol'ed."

Cerberusx said...

Insanity I dub thy ponies!

Also, I will admit that all mares going into heat at the same time would be scarie as hell. But one has to wonder why some stallions haven't taken advantage of such a thing...or have they???

Cali-Nipponia said...

Yeah, it does require a bit of suspension of disbelief, but the premise is humorous enough to be worth it.

As for the rape bit, yes, by definition rape is bad. Do note that it hasn't actually happened, however. Chapter 1, folks, cliffhanger ending. He'll almost certainly find some way of escaping at the beginning of chapter 2.

Brongaar said...

It is a good setup even he got into the trap of RD being seemingly fillyfoolish.

How is the Big Red Stud gonna get out of Luna's clutches?

Tune in at the same time and channel?

leictreon said...

I normally wouldn't read shipping, clopping or stuff like that.

But seeing a fic where the mares AREN'T lesbians is such an oddity. I think i'll give this one a try.

saltnpeppa said...

lololol the heart in Derpy's eye is upside-down!

Sandman said...

Cant wait to see Chapter 2.

bronyjoe said...

brilliant! i can't wait to see how this one goes.

Anthony S. said...

This is gonna be good. Can't wait for chapter 2.

Onlinowiec said...

It would be all great and cool... BUT 1 thing isn't ok. The author said it's "completed". [SAD FACE] I want MOAAAAAAAAAAAARRR :(

Travis Smith said...

So I read it wrong and the author was just joking with the dash shipping. Okay I'm back on board

DPV111 said...

@Cali-Nipponia
Uh... It's complete.

@Brongaar
It wasn't a trap. It was a prank.

@leictreon
Ther is no shipping. There ARE lesbians.

@Travis Smith
You need to take shipping less seriously, especially in a comedy fic. Especially considering all the other content in this fic, a little tiny reference to AppleDash "ruining" it for you seems a little extreme.

Travis Smith said...

@DPV111
It's just something I try to avoid it when I can. I didn't say I would stop reading it, and I'm trying to take a little less, like Silent Ponyville 2 is a Dash ship but I really like the story of it.

Drwhoof said...

This is so damn good! Please don't be a one shot!

Farnor said...

google docs version please!

Ardashir said...

Bwa-haha! Poor Big Mac, you really got to pity the stud. The whole thing is vaguely reminiscent of a Hope and Crosby movie.

Hmm, I do wonder, though -- where were Snips and Snails? Locked in their room(s) by their mothers to save their innocent colts from being ravished by stallion-hungry mares?

TenchiFreak5 said...

This was some funny shit. Not the most well-written of stories, but most of the gags worked well enough; and the ending was hilarious .

Bryan said...

@Ardashir Snips and Snails are underage. Let's try not to think about where the children are during the rapepocalypse.

herpyderpy said...

This was a damn fun fic to read, I normally try and avoid shipping but this was in no way your typical shipfic.

Reminds me of all those zombie apocalypse movies, except they don't want brains, they want to screw you to death!

Jazz said...

WHEATLEY!!!! (Fancy Pants)
NOOOOOO!!! *he had some awesome jammies

Was getting a bit saucy at the beggining of the second part. And where did the stallions flee to??

FlintLock said...

Update post says evening, but it's not evening. (Eastern time zone). Something is off about this...

DPV111 said...

New chapter was nice wrap up.
Portraying the scene in Canterlot akin to a zombie apocalypse gave the story just the right tongue in cheek that the first chapter was sorely lacking.

TenchiFreak5 said...

I agree with DPV. I like the first chapter, but this one just was so much... better. I think the reason so many people objected to the first was that it wasn't as obvious how silly it was supposed to be (outside of the scenes with Rainbow Dash), and this one did a good job correcting that.

Ardashir said...

@Bryan So it's like on planet Vulcan? "When the Pon(y) Far hits, you can but hide the elders and the foals?"

Post a Comment