I like those month themed songs, wasn't this one posted a day or two ago? If so, this is probably a different version of. Anyway, love #1, certainly odd, but it's still a very good song.
@Koolfox A huge and somewhat confusing debate… I’ve listened to yours on repeat, too. Can’t decide. I really like both your music.
Yours has the advantage that I can hear both of you in it, and the different voices help convey the time difference between the narration and the story, and also differences in character. But I think I’ll just wait a month and then consult my last.fm stats.
@Koolfox Both versions are definitely fantastic, although I have to say that I think I prefer Mic's. Your version is fantastic, but I think his just works a bit more given the song's narrative. Either way, both yours and Mic's are beautiful.
#3: The Beatles and ponies = awesome. Though I really would love to hear a cover of Dig a Pony, the best song from the album, and arguably most fitting.
Putting these 3 types of genres in a single post kinda disturbs my opinion -.-
#1: 7/10 - I enjoyed it. Didn't enjoy the lyrics during the shouting part, but the idea was good.
#2: 6/10 - I enjoyed the lyrics and vocals, it started off bland so I listened again and it eased up so, I think the first song corrupted it, though I enjoyed the ending.
#3: 6/10 - The intro made me laugh, then the song completely reminded me of Family Guy, so I think that ruined the entire image, lol. I enjoyed the duo vocals and guitar, but the vocals felt forced in a couple brief moments. Overall enjoyed it.
#1 I feel bad I thought this was the original by Tomb that was already posted earlier. lol But after listening to the two of them, I can see now they're different. I like this version slightly more than Tomb's I think. But these are both good. :D
#2 Wasn't bad. Singing was alright. The lyrics are pretty decent. Didn't rhyme as much as I typically like I don't think. lol But they don't have to, to be to good. That's just my own preference. Think you did a nice job on it.
#3 Well, this is certainly a little interesting. lol Based on a Beatles song. Was wondering why it sounded kinda familiar. Didn't care much for the singing, it's so/so. Lyrics so/so too I s'pose. I will say it did remind me of some Beatles songs at least. :P
@Koolfox Gotta say, I think I prefer Mic's more, I think overall he has the better voice for the song and he pulls off the insanity near the end quite a bit better (no offense Mic xD). But yours was great too and props for thinking of the lyrics and making the track its a really great song.
#1: Not that the original wasn't awesome but this cover was just great. #2: Even though I don't like this type of music, it was really well done. All in all, a win. =)
@Koolfox I've listened to your version I think, eight or nine times since it came out. xD That said, I've grown more accustomed to yours. Although mic's voice is clearer than yours on it, I like the element your accent adds to the song.
32 comments:
hi
I like those month themed songs, wasn't this one posted a day or two ago? If so, this is probably a different version of. Anyway, love #1, certainly odd, but it's still a very good song.
@superdeluxeultra Good day
I’ve been listening to #1 on repeat, and #3 ist great too. I still have to listen to #2.
Yeah, I dig the singing style in #2. :-)
There is a huge debate on which singer was better for the song September, what do you guys think? Did Mic sing better then me or not?
- The Living Tombstone
#2's a very good song. Nice little story being told with it. Good lyrics.
Parts of #3 remind me of Stuck In The Middle With You. Okay song, nice rhythm.
@Koolfox I like yours more, Tombstone.
It's amazing how the Beatle Bronies got Two of Us out in under 11 hours after the episode aired.
I didn't notice it being mentioned here, so here's a song I gave them the lyrics for, Bloomberg:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JHthDwmqXI0
@Koolfox A huge and somewhat confusing debate… I’ve listened to yours on repeat, too. Can’t decide. I really like both your music.
Yours has the advantage that I can hear both of you in it, and the different voices help convey the time difference between the narration and the story, and also differences in character. But I think I’ll just wait a month and then consult my last.fm stats.
@Koolfox
I'd have to go with Mic.
@SonofMrPeanut I listen to that one earlier today. So cute!
@Koolfox
Both versions are definitely fantastic, although I have to say that I think I prefer Mic's. Your version is fantastic, but I think his just works a bit more given the song's narrative. Either way, both yours and Mic's are beautiful.
#3: The Beatles and ponies = awesome. Though I really would love to hear a cover of Dig a Pony, the best song from the album, and arguably most fitting.
#2 is brilliant!
#3 Beatle Bronies, I may not care for Beatles music, but you have to give these guys credit for how fast they are with making awesome covers
@Koolfox
Well, both are good, but I liked Mic's cover a tad more. His version sounded more vocally consistent and lyrically clearer.
Putting these 3 types of genres in a single post kinda disturbs my opinion -.-
#1: 7/10 - I enjoyed it. Didn't enjoy the lyrics during the shouting part, but the idea was good.
#2: 6/10 - I enjoyed the lyrics and vocals, it started off bland so I listened again and it eased up so, I think the first song corrupted it, though I enjoyed the ending.
#3: 6/10 - The intro made me laugh, then the song completely reminded me of Family Guy, so I think that ruined the entire image, lol. I enjoyed the duo vocals and guitar, but the vocals felt forced in a couple brief moments. Overall enjoyed it.
#1 I feel bad I thought this was the original by Tomb that was already posted earlier. lol But after listening to the two of them, I can see now they're different. I like this version slightly more than Tomb's I think. But these are both good. :D
#2 Wasn't bad. Singing was alright. The lyrics are pretty decent. Didn't rhyme as much as I typically like I don't think. lol But they don't have to, to be to good. That's just my own preference. Think you did a nice job on it.
#3 Well, this is certainly a little interesting. lol Based on a Beatles song. Was wondering why it sounded kinda familiar. Didn't care much for the singing, it's so/so. Lyrics so/so too I s'pose. I will say it did remind me of some Beatles songs at least. :P
@Koolfox
Gotta say, I think I prefer Mic's more, I think overall he has the better voice for the song and he pulls off the insanity near the end quite a bit better (no offense Mic xD). But yours was great too and props for thinking of the lyrics and making the track its a really great song.
#1: Not that the original wasn't awesome but this cover was just great.
#2: Even though I don't like this type of music, it was really well done. All in all, a win.
=)
@Sheffield Makoto
What reminded you of Family Guy? I'm just curious.
@Koolfox
I liked both of your versions. There were elements in your singing that I liked better than his, and vice versa. Either way, fantastic song!
Love the community and their music!
I am so going to do a fan art for this September... !
The mental image of that pony yelling and laughing around to an empty city is extremely appealing.
YEAH!! love these vocals.
i think music should really get its own catagory at the top. cause there sure is a lot of it!
@Koolfox
Yours is better. Mic's is shit. He said so himself.
trollface.jpg
@Koolfox
I've listened to your version I think, eight or nine times since it came out. xD That said, I've grown more accustomed to yours. Although mic's voice is clearer than yours on it, I like the element your accent adds to the song.
What they need to do is make songs for all the months, and then I can make my rotational starting music :D, and other such things.
@Koolfox They're both good, but I think I like Mic's better. Clearer vocals, slightly better harmony and his voice just 'fit' better I think.
@Koolfox anangrygoldfish here. Did you base September off a fanfic? If not, then I call dibs on writing one
1. Sweet! I'm really liking all the artists working together lately.
2. That's a really cool perspective!
3. The vocals are a bit strained, but I still really liked it.
@Koolfox
Not gonna lie, I absolutely love your voice. It has an interesting and unique quality to it.
I love mic, but I loved your vocals more.
Post a Comment