Saturday, September 3, 2011

Poll Results: Who Is the Best Antagonist?

I think we know who won already.  I'm glad so many agree with the SUPERIORITY that is TRIXIE!

Taking requests again.  Toss them in the comments. 

117 comments:

ZAquanimus said...

Awwwww YEAH

NMM is best (bad)pony.!

Warp said...

Best /RP/ persona or best ponied video game?

Fall Silently said...

Next poll: Best Griffin.

clarin-ed said...

How many times do you visit EqD daily? (suggested poll)

Masterge77 said...

OH YES! Nightmare Moon WON!

I can't wait to see what Discord is like...

Temp1261 said...

Favorite Background pony? Or has that been done before?

Skytower said...

Which inanimate object is best inanimate object?

bronydash said...

How about what band you'd like to see make a cameo on the show? Maybe a little vague, but I'm sure Seth can make it worse.

CTOONfan1 said...

Here's a poll idea:

Who do you want to see the most again in Season 2?

Don't know if that's been done yet.

Unknown said...

Poll: How many friends have you converted to MLP?

johnlmonkey said...

Trollestia really should've been a choice for that poll.

rikvb9olp said...

Favorite cupcake flavor! trolololololol

Crunch said...

Best CMC pony? Or was that done already?

AlbiCJH said...

Damn, Trixie deserves #1!

Oh, and best pony insanity moments?

Ford said...

Have we already done best pet? I don't think I've seen one like that yet.

Philomena would have to be excluded, unfortunately, as she's already scored second to dragons.

Torchman said...

Poll: Best real life musical pony artist.

Flutterguy said...

Favorite pony pun. Ex. Phillydelphia and Manehatten

Dragryphon said...

I am most certainly the best antagonist in the show.

David Reinold said...

Favorite Pinkie Pie imaginary friend.

*Nyx* Griffin said...

what element of harmony would YOU want to have?....or was that already done?...

bookman said...

What about favorite Gala Dress?

Clp605 said...

Things that have not yet be ponified but should. I would make a list suggestion but I can't think of any.

Fawfulcopter said...

Thunderhooves isn't an antagonist, Silverstar is!

coleknows said...

Best remixer/brony dj

Narwhals' Bend said...

I like Trixie, but NMM is best antagonist.

Trollestia said...

@johnlmonkey

I'll have you know I am NOT an antagonist, I try to make a few jokes and maybe banish Blueblood a few times and everyone thinks im evil.

Salvinaude said...

What is your favorite type of pony stuff? Like clothes, art, videos, games, fanfiction, games, etc.,etc. stuff like that?
Or what about most awesome we have seen any pony do in any episode?

Ryex said...

WHO IS THE BEST BLOG-PONY!?!?
Make a poll and then we'll know!

SkyrimOrBust said...

Pony you'd be most afraid to get in a fight with.

kelzae said...

How long have you been in the fandom?

ninto55 said...

Poll idea-

Is anything better without ponies?

Ponies make EVERYTHING better!
Ponies can't possibly hurt anything.
Some crossovers might not be a good idea for the non bronies.
Some crossovers might not be a good idea for everyone.
All crossovers are awful, I want my ponies as they are!

Honestly I don't know what I'd pick, but it'd probably be the first.

EpsillonXD said...

How often do you visit EqD?

Ddude28 said...

What is your favourite media from the fandom.

(video games, fan fiction, fan art, etc)

Thesyn said...

Nightmare is best.

Ogrecakes said...

The best Pinkamina Imaginary friend?

I have a feeling thats already been done though...

Unknown said...

Poll: Do you think Rainbow Dash is a lesbian?

or

Poll: What do you think happened to Rainbow Dash that made her color-less?

Rhed said...

Trixie is the best!

ProBrono said...

I refrained from voting on this one because I wasn't sure how to answer it. What does "best antagonist" mean? Nightmare Moon was the most competent/fleshed-out as a character, Gilda and Trixie were the most vindictive, Diamond Tiara was the most unlikeable, the parasprites were the most destructive, and Blueblood was the most hilarious. How am I supposed to pick just one?

yik_omega said...

Awesomest person that works on the show besides Faust?

Wraithwood said...

given the resent "fan art" of Cereal-Seth i vote for best crack Ship.

Gummy said...

How about who you would like to see make a cameo appearance in the show. Ex. like weird al.

ShakeBunny said...

Poll idea. On a scale of one through five, how much would you say MLP:FiM has affected your life?

Phantomsniper said...

WOOOO go Nightmare Moon

InkyPie said...

No silly, the Great and Powerful Trixie is no antagonist that's not how you write STAR.

Also, poll idea: Best dress. Mane 6+ Photo Finish + Saphire Shores (maybe you can think of more than I do at 1:20 AM)

Nos said...

@Trollestia
I don't think banishing Blueblood makes you evil
Banishing Luna however...

Blinky said...

Poll ideas:

What is your favorite song?
How excited are you for season 2?
What kind of personality will Luna have?
Should the show have more male characters?

Trollestia said...

@Nos

That was one time, and she was sort of...well evil then. I only banish idiots now.

Practical jokes however? everypony gets them.

Nos said...

@Trollestia
Speaking of jokes. Did you hear about how Celestia got turned into a filly and then Luna set up a fake rebellion?

Mettie7 said...

How often do you visit EqD?

Latias4Ever said...

And THAT, is why I love Nightmare Moon and Trixie, they're so epic.

Pinstar said...

Favorite Pony Pet
Winona
Gummy
Opal
Angel Bunny
Owliscious(sp)

KShrike said...

You are blind, sir...
Nightmare moon won.
Although...
there weren't any REAL antagonists.
Also wondering why there were not enough Gilda votes.

Pony In Chief said...

Ironically, Trixie is the royal pain-in-the ass.
Next poll should be: 'Are EQD visitors creative poll creators?'

Atiarotias said...

I'm seeing a lot of "How often visit EqD" but does anyone even remember?
I think I check like 20~30 times? or may be more.

Markus said...

Best Town or City.

Pony In Chief said...

Scratch my creativity poll.
Ask the bronies 'For what reason do you select fanfics to read?'
Ie: you chose it for the 5/6 star rating, the title, the description, characters, authors, etc.

Trollestia said...

@Nos

And she was eating nothing but alfalfa for a week afterwards.

Luke said...

What's The Blue Pony With The Hourglass Cutiemark's Real Name?

Romana
Not Colgate
Still Not Colgate
Stop Saying Colgate You Foal!

Ewyndall said...

I voted Nightmare Moon because for me Trixie is not an antagonist.
Yes she IS obnoxious and smug and bragging and classy and all, but she didn't do ANYTHING 'antagonisty' apart from having the potential of becoming a great one with such personality :)

basshero2407 said...

You should do a poll on everypony's favorite episode

Cryptonik said...

best pony couple :[]

Raditz 360 said...

Trixie is the Mr. satan hercule of mlp
nightmare moon for the win

Dr.Cthulu said...

Age I want to know how old everyone is

Sir Payne said...

You could ask how often everyone watches the actual episodes

Sofii said...

Best Shipping Couple.

johnlmonkey said...

@Trollestia
Quick question, do you like mmmm bananas?

randomdefence said...

Get an actual age poll of people who visit the site.

Trollestia said...

@johnlmonkey

*eyetwitch* Don't you tempt me.

esiewertjr said...

Which Pony looks best in a hat? Trixie, Applejack, Rarity, Fluttershy, etc etc ^^

The_Owl said...

Who is your least favourite supporting character?

Stormcloud said...

Next Poll: Who is the cutest pony?

duffdawg said...

I'm not sure if this poll was a great idea. I don't really think there have been that many "antagonists" in the show. Nightmare Moon was the only traditional antagonist in my opinion. I went with Gilda to be a contrarian and also because she had pretty much no positive attributes. Also as far as the dragons there were 2 of different colors so that should have been more specific. Also, Sethisto clearly voted for Trixie 2000 times using mod hax. This has been your whiny critic, signing off.

jet2112112 said...

*Sees that Trixie is number 2* *Tries to hold back a laugh and fails* BUAAAAHAHAHAAA-*Keeps laughing*

But on a serious note, I hate Trixie. Her attitude is so..whats the word? ... Ah, its vile. No, its worse but I can't think of a good word to describe it. I guess its so annoying to hear her say that shes better than everypony else (Of course shes not! As Twilight showed har har har). OH and don't get me started on her saying her own Celestia damn name over and over!

Sorry about that. I just needed to get that out.

sbm1992 said...

favourite pinkemina party guest?

Octavia said...

I voted Trixie. She's great at what she does. :P

Fleymevas said...

I wasn't sure how to answer this poll really. I like Trixie and all but I never truly saw her as an "antagonist".

And I wasn't sure how to define "best antagonist". "Best" as in greatest villain or "best" as in favorite character?

I just chose Nightmare Moon because she is a cool villain I guess.

Zogger568 said...

If FiM were to ever be acted out by live people, what would be more important to you; the voice or the appearance of the characters?

NoxNomasSanguine said...

Age. That's the most interesting to me.

Mr. Shiny Object said...

Best magic trick (telekinesis, teleportation, suits, mustaches, wings, carriages, etc.)

Avery Strange said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Avery Strange said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Pyrtan said...

May have already been said. But! How many times a day do you check EQD?

Avery Strange said...

Request: To see you and Cereal touch horns again.

....oh wait you mean like for a poll? Hey how about we turn our eyes on the community? Sure you can't include them all, but take a dozen of the big music bronies and see who's on top. Or maybe just go more a step up and figure out what genre of music bronies love the most. Oh hey was there a fic genre poll? That'd be interesting too.

But seriously, Seth x Cereal OTP

Polaris said...

The ponies who taunt Rainbow Dash in Cloudsdale: Dumb-Bell, Hoops and Score.

Polaris said...

Huh, this is an answer to D'artagnan.

bookman said...

Best member of the mane 6 as a filly?

Smokey Treble said...

@Fawfulcopter
I was just going to say, in no way was Thunderhooves an antagonist any more than Silverstar was.

DRTJR said...

Best Flier.
Rainbow Dash
Fluttershy
Gilda
Philomina
Pinkie pie
Red Dragon

Logan Warner said...

Next poll should ask if you clop to ponies. I think there was a poll like that on Ponibooru recently but that was a terribly small sample, would be interesting to see what the results are for here.

Apsuenbwyfer11 said...

suggested poll: Do you clop to clopfics?
1. Whats a "clopfic"?
2. EWW NO
3. hmm....nah
4. I read them but I don't clop
5. *clopclopclopclop*

did i miss any possible options?

Mustang said...

I knew she would win.

Scout said...

Poll Request: What month did you become a Brony/join the herd?

The "month" section of the question is the critical part. Being September, this will be the last time that FiM has existed for 12 unique months. Therefore, a poll with 12 choices, starting with October and ending with September, would provide a unique opportunity to see the growth of the fandom over the past year. It would also be interesting to see what month spawned the most Bronies.

Doing this poll this month would be ideal, because you would not even need to include year numbers in the voting options.

sammwich said...

I second the best pet poll, but Scootaloo needs to be on the list.

Vermillion Twilight said...

Just a nitpick, but which dragon was in the poll? Yeh, I figure the red one from Dragonshy since the episode centered around him as a threat, but arguably he was pretty laid back compared to the green dragon in Owl's Well That Ends Well who was out for murder.

Thunderhooves should not have been on this list.

The cockatrice got way too few votes. I mean, he had already 'killed' Twilight by turning her to stone, was going to kill the CMC before Fluttershy stepped in and, in probably the greatest display of pony bad-ass, stared it down until it was a total submissive bitch AS IT WAS KILLING HER.

joetraincool said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
joetraincool said...

Just a few poll submission ideas:

Average Age;

How many times people visit a day;

Favorite cameo (Weird Al, Iron Mareden, etc.)

Just a few suggestions.

Mattwo said...

Nightmare moon may be good compared to most of the rest but she set a rather low standard >.<

Zurkoslat said...

Poll: What is your occupation type that you are going for or already are.

For example artist, scientist,tech guy, engineer law, literature, cook? you know genre. there's probably an easier way to say this.

I also think this would be a cool poll to see what sort of people make up the community.

Pacce said...

Alright, 738 of you have GOOD taste.

Dr.Cthulu said...

Which Mane 6 pony would be properly shipped with Big Mac

Poco said...

Hmmm... I see everyone's wrong again.

duffdawg said...

I second Scout's poll idea.

Kjh242 said...

I think this poll was unfairly gray.
NMM was a pretty great character as an antagonist, but
Gilda was the best ANTAGONIST- she did it right, antagonists are supposed to make you dislike them.

TuxRug said...

I voted NMM because half of those aren't even really antagonists so far. I know an antagonist is very different from a villain, but I really don't feel like Trixie, Gilda, or Blueblood are antagonists.

Unknown said...

Scout's poll Request is cool. Use it!

Laurence Brown said...

Poll question: What mythical creature would you like to see show up in season two?
Some ideas for the poll:
Trolls
Giants
Rocs
Chimeras
Centaurs
Pixies

Heck, and anything from Dungeons and Dragons could be used too, since Hasbro owns that also. Grab a Monster Manual, flip to a random page or three, and toss out some cool looking things to round out the poll!

ryan said...

Next Poll:
Which characters do you think Hasbro will give fan-made personalities?
(multiple choice)
All of them
None
Derpy Hooves
Lyra
Bon-Bon
etc

thunderhooves said...

no one likes me?

awwhhh....

Brightshine said...

Thunderhooves, everypony likes you!Nopony thought you were evil, which is a good thing! *hugs the buffalo*

-Brightshine-

megantron said...

@clarin-ed Good one.

I really like the polls that ask about the reader demographics. I know there have been several polls about gender and age, but maybe we could have more demographic polls...maybe for race or ethnic group/nationality/sexual orientation/income or education level, etc? I know at EqD those aren't as big a deal at other forums/communities, but I still think it's interesting to see the makeup of any community.

DoubleMallow said...

If superiority is connected with magic, then that is SOME inferiority on Trixie's part.

Faaiz said...

How about best pet? You know, like Gummy or Angel, or Opal.

Ham said...

Best Apple family member. AJ, Big Mac, Apple Bloom, Granny Smith, or Braeburn.

Favo said...

Nightmare Moon won. Shut the fuck up, Seth.

Post a Comment