When I saw Naylor's picture on 4chan (before all this shit have started) I was like F*ck! OMG. WHY??? I am not offending J. Naylor, but the fact that he made human-ponies freaks me out D=
When Jay Naylor a selfish, misogynistic randroid, closet-homo in denial who obsesses over manliness likes this show enough to put more effort into a humanized drawing of the ponies than his comic strip you have to stop and think about what kind of people the haters are.
The clothes fit their personalities plus the cutie marks are incorporated in them, Angel is also present on the picture. I'm pretty sure he watched more than 10 seconds of it not to mention this isn't a comission, according to his FA page he did on his own for practice.
I actually found, that I love Rarity on Naylor's picture. If only Pinkie could be normal and Applejack not so like-from-comics, I could enjoy whole picture.
The only ones I find somewhat appropriate in Naylor's picture are Rarity and Rainbow Dash. Not too much of a fan of his art style though. And that Pinkie Pie looks like she is straight out of Cupcakes... /shudder
Yet even I (and many of my friends) do NOT want to see the ponies sexualized.
They're sweet and innocent and should stay that way! That's one of the things that makes them so awesome. Hopefully Jay doesn't go any "further" with this.
I think it is harmless that that guy is drawing humanized ponies (isn't that the opposite of what furries do?). It looks good and if he keeps his MLP stuff like this, then I don't see any problem with it
Hey, I'm okay if he draws anthropomorphic versions of the ponies. As long as it's not rule 34 stuff, it's all kosher.
I've actually seen some good 'morphic depictions of the ponies that are tasteful and awesome, but they stay mostly confined to furry websites like FA. It seems other pony fans don't want to see it, and I'm okay with that. :)
waiiit, i know that artist. he draws stuff. though he does draw it quite well so im good as long as things don't get that wierd. *pointing to the humanized shiny picture*
Naylor is my favorite furry artist (yes, I'm a furfag, and no, I don't want rule 34 of ponies, it's too pure for that kind of shit, I'm ok with shipping though). But now I see this and I fucking love the guy.
Totally cool with morphic and "human" ponies, but I understand why this site mainly keeps to the art that is the normal style, which is the type of artwork for FiM I enjoy the most.
Seen plenty of morphic and human stuff on ponibooru, so it does manage to make some of the rounds.
The rule 34 stuff, well that ship sailed on day one, but I don't think any of that should be posted here, same with clop fic. If people like those things its fine, but there are places you can go for them already.
ah theres some good rule 34 human and pony version of this but then again a few people ruin it and theres random disenboweled pony's with cupcakes the story was really good but we don't need to see that >.> clop fics you can find easily enough on fanfiction.net though that one yesterday with gilda was one and rather good read at that.
people have been freaking out over naylor but i don't think anyone's mentioned that the art is *fucking terrible*. he draws in a style I've never liked to begin with, but humanizing ponies (which alone I think generally is a bad thing that destroys the point of the whole "cute ponies" thing unless pulled off exceptionally well) and making them look this disgusting... shit, I hope we don't have to see too much more crap like this when we wade around this site and ponibooru.
Being as I am unfamiliar with this Jay Naylor fellow, I can't bring myself to be 'offended' at the humanized ponies. Actually, I think it's kind of cool, if nothing else, because of the extremely believable designs. They seem to really capture the characters in a humanesqe manner. Especially Rainbow Dash and, in my opinion, Pinkie Pie.
In other news - Ponies D&D is still great. Friendship crit. Awesome.
What's wrong with humanized versions? I understand the hating of furfags (even if we bronies shouldn't "hate" that much). But there are many humanized versions and I like them, it's pretty creative.
...so...yeah...how about that last one! I actually kind of thought Twilight was trying to go for a "wizardy" kinda vibe with that dress in the first place.
Twilight playing D&D AND dressing up for it just makes me snicker incessantly.
And...does Fluttershy have a little Cthulhu in her saddlebag? That's fantastic.
Whoo hoo another drawfriend so quickly! The Luna one is awesome! oh man Naylor... Don't get me wrong I love humanized ponies Its fun to see traits get reflected into human form but Naylor's just made my cringe with disapproval as Don_ko said earlier most uncomfortable
@sethisto furry's arn't that bad. im not one personaly, anthro go for it just pure animals kinda :/ though their not that bad, much worse groups then them to raid us :)
May I ask something? If it was the exact same picture, down to a t, but drawn by some one else, would you guys be criticizing it the same way? Forget that it looks like 'his' characters, forget that it was drawn by a 'furry'. Forget that it was drawn by him for just a minute, and look at the picture itself. How is it then? Also, it seems kind of obvious from the comments that not all furries want to see Rule 34 of MLP. So, could we not rag on an entire group? We're kind of close to sinking to 4chan's level, in that regard.
Wow... no offense, but - Jay Naylor gets such a reaction, even if it is negative, that us newer artists kinda get drowned out, reaction wise. All there is, is Naylor Naylor Naylor... admittedly, I feel sorry for him, making a fairly innocent fanpic that winds up with such a huge negative reaction simply because he was the one who did it, but still, it's the fact that he did it that got it such a reaction. It's kinda daunting.
-(Chooses one of the other pics - any of them - to comment on)- I love the D&D Pic with Twilight Sparkle's 'dress of fail'. It is so wizardy, and yet so awesome. Snips and Snails working in a broach shop like a couple of mechanics is just awesome, as well. And in regards to the Derpy Hooves pics - Happy Derpy Day everybody! There! Now leave Naylor alone!
I suspect a lot of the criticism is specifically because it is Naylor.
The image itself is alright, not really sure if I like the style or not. Don't care for how Applejack or Pinkie looks but I do like how Twilight and Rarity are portrayed.
Jay Naylor is a very talented artist and even a fair storymaker that has sadly fallen prey to wasting his time on making porn and leaving his main comics to suffer.
Just search New World by Jay Naylor to see what I mean on his potental and compare it to his Better Days comic.
Also some of his misconceptions on government and his... political views have bleed over to MLP FiM. Just read his One Pony comic to see what I mean: http://www.furaffinity.net/view/7292186/ I even make a post where I had Celestia made an actual reply to Big Mac's letter.
75 comments:
Naylor? Really?
Furry artists don't draw Spike.\
Just something I noticed.
Needs more pony DnD, its adoranle
When I saw Naylor's picture on 4chan (before all this shit have started) I was like F*ck! OMG. WHY??? I am not offending J. Naylor, but the fact that he made human-ponies freaks me out D=
And Applejack... -_-
There's a Derpy on the wing! JUST LOOK! IT'S ON THE WING!
/Shatner
Wow holy crap, yea I didnt see naylor being the type for ponys...
Jay Naylor.
Hoooo-llyyyy crap.
That's clearly Corrupted Ashbringer.
Who Jay Naylor? And why are you guys acting the way you are?
The Gummy with Dash one has to be more favorite, although the Rainbow Bros one is pretty cute too.
As for Naylor, I guess it shows FiM can turn almost anyone into a bronie, even hard core Objectivists.
Still not sure why him drawing human ponies is any more "freaky" then all the others.
@Naxts
He is a furry porn comics artist. I (we) just feel uncomfortable to receive ponies from him.
And his Applejack looks too similar with one of his comics character. I don't want to see ponies in that way ((
@Don_ko
Yea I agree with this.
I remember when he posted his stuff under a different name and it was all Sonic-style fan characters. I smell bandwagon jumping.
@Anonymous
I smell conspiracy.
When Jay Naylor a selfish, misogynistic randroid, closet-homo in denial who obsesses over manliness likes this show enough to put more effort into a humanized drawing of the ponies than his comic strip you have to stop and think about what kind of people the haters are.
Anyone else think Naylors Pinkie looks kind of.. gone? Like she's either high or about to make cupcakes?
Dammit Naylor why do u confuse me so.
I like the art but it reminds me too much of all the shit he has drawn.
And the worst part is you can clearly see he has actually watched to show. It might be a commission but still, he might have even enjoyed it.
@Anonymous
The clothes fit their personalities plus the cutie marks are incorporated in them, Angel is also present on the picture. I'm pretty sure he watched more than 10 seconds of it not to mention this isn't a comission, according to his FA page he did on his own for practice.
@Mads
Yeah, he noted in his comments that he was getting tired around the right side of the pic and Pinkie suffered.
I love Twilight's D&D outfit!
But why Twilight in this picture has white skin?
@Anonymous
But why she should has another color?!
I actually found, that I love Rarity on Naylor's picture. If only Pinkie could be normal and Applejack not so like-from-comics, I could enjoy whole picture.
The only ones I find somewhat appropriate in Naylor's picture are Rarity and Rainbow Dash. Not too much of a fan of his art style though. And that Pinkie Pie looks like she is straight out of Cupcakes... /shudder
Note: I am a furry.
Yet even I (and many of my friends) do NOT want to see the ponies sexualized.
They're sweet and innocent and should stay that way! That's one of the things that makes them so awesome. Hopefully Jay doesn't go any "further" with this.
Lol.
"RainBros"
I think it is harmless that that guy is drawing humanized ponies (isn't that the opposite of what furries do?). It looks good and if he keeps his MLP stuff like this, then I don't see any problem with it
@Anonymous
Hey, I'm okay if he draws anthropomorphic versions of the ponies. As long as it's not rule 34 stuff, it's all kosher.
I've actually seen some good 'morphic depictions of the ponies that are tasteful and awesome, but they stay mostly confined to furry websites like FA. It seems other pony fans don't want to see it, and I'm okay with that. :)
waiiit, i know that artist. he draws stuff. though he does draw it quite well so im good as long as things don't get that wierd. *pointing to the humanized shiny picture*
Naylor is my favorite furry artist (yes, I'm a furfag, and no, I don't want rule 34 of ponies, it's too pure for that kind of shit, I'm ok with shipping though). But now I see this and I fucking love the guy.
Totally cool with morphic and "human" ponies, but I understand why this site mainly keeps to the art that is the normal style, which is the type of artwork for FiM I enjoy the most.
Seen plenty of morphic and human stuff on ponibooru, so it does manage to make some of the rounds.
The rule 34 stuff, well that ship sailed on day one, but I don't think any of that should be posted here, same with clop fic. If people like those things its fine, but there are places you can go for them already.
@brianblackberry
Do tell.
If we're willing to keep going as close as the Twilight/Rarity 'magic book' fic, that would be just fine by me. I prefer that level anyway.
Inspirational. Not Penthouse Forum.
@brianblackberry
ah theres some good rule 34 human and pony version of this but then again a few people ruin it and theres random disenboweled pony's with cupcakes the story was really good but we don't need to see that >.> clop fics you can find easily enough on fanfiction.net though that one yesterday with gilda was one and rather good read at that.
Fucking Naylor
Fuck Naylor and Fuck furfags.
You are the black scum stuck in the water filter of humanity.
people have been freaking out over naylor but i don't think anyone's mentioned that the art is *fucking terrible*. he draws in a style I've never liked to begin with, but humanizing ponies (which alone I think generally is a bad thing that destroys the point of the whole "cute ponies" thing unless pulled off exceptionally well) and making them look this disgusting... shit, I hope we don't have to see too much more crap like this when we wade around this site and ponibooru.
@Anonymous
dude, that's not very loving of you :P
but seriously people that naylor pic just creeps me out..
maybe his changing his turning his life around and dropping the porno furry pics!
That my pony friends is the power of MLP.
So which of the Elements of Harmony encompasses calling people furfags and scum?
There's a Derpy on the wing of the plane! You've got to believe me!
Yay, another Zecora pic! And thanks for the laugh with Twilight using her bad dress as a wizard outfit.
So is Kloudmutt back? Or is that just a recently colored version of a Cheerilee pic?
Being as I am unfamiliar with this Jay Naylor fellow, I can't bring myself to be 'offended' at the humanized ponies. Actually, I think it's kind of cool, if nothing else, because of the extremely believable designs. They seem to really capture the characters in a humanesqe manner. Especially Rainbow Dash and, in my opinion, Pinkie Pie.
In other news - Ponies D&D is still great. Friendship crit. Awesome.
@Anonymous
There is a troll for every thread.
What's wrong with humanized versions? I understand the hating of furfags (even if we bronies shouldn't "hate" that much). But there are many humanized versions and I like them, it's pretty creative.
@Anonymous
Haters gonna hate. :)
...so...yeah...how about that last one! I actually kind of thought Twilight was trying to go for a "wizardy" kinda vibe with that dress in the first place.
Twilight playing D&D AND dressing up for it just makes me snicker incessantly.
And...does Fluttershy have a little Cthulhu in her saddlebag? That's fantastic.
Gonna be honest.
When I first saw someone else draw human ponies, I thought to myself "Huh. I wonder what they would look like if Jay Naylor drew them."
Now I know. Not sure if that's a good thing or a bad thing, but now I know.
Whoo hoo another drawfriend so quickly!
The Luna one is awesome!
oh man Naylor...
Don't get me wrong I love humanized ponies Its fun to see traits get reflected into human form but Naylor's just made my cringe with disapproval
as Don_ko said earlier most uncomfortable
Inkwell in regards to Frostmane: Woohoo! I got on Drawfriend! Yay!
wait, is that a Kloudmutt picture? Has he finally returned?
If so, HOORAY
I just realized with the Derpy one, is that a reference to the Twilight Zone episode with William Shatner seeing the goblin on the wing?
@brianblackberry
Yes.
That luna picture is absolutely beautiful.
Could I get a source on that?
@brianblackberry
Somepony may or may not have made that reference in this very comments section 9 hours ago.
Is it me or does Naylor's Twilight
Sparkle look just like Beth from Better Days?
>Wake up expecting to see a /b/ raid on the blog and 300 comments to delete
>Find a furry raid instead
never change /co/!
@sethisto furry's arn't that bad. im not one personaly, anthro go for it just pure animals kinda :/ though their not that bad, much worse groups then them to raid us :)
Exit does not exist
Call back to http://www.equestriadaily.com/2011/01/comic-rainbow-dashs-letter-to.html?
May I ask something?
If it was the exact same picture, down to a t, but drawn by some one else, would you guys be criticizing it the same way?
Forget that it looks like 'his' characters, forget that it was drawn by a 'furry'. Forget that it was drawn by him for just a minute, and look at the picture itself. How is it then?
Also, it seems kind of obvious from the comments that not all furries want to see Rule 34 of MLP. So, could we not rag on an entire group? We're kind of close to sinking to 4chan's level, in that regard.
@hikuro
Here you go, http://luna-sedata.deviantart.com/
Also I drew that one, so thanks! Maybe someday it'll be finished
Naylor or no, it's still pretty cool!
God, Naylor is an awful artist. His faces are hideous. :|
@Pecan
/wordsofwisdom
Wow... no offense, but - Jay Naylor gets such a reaction, even if it is negative, that us newer artists kinda get drowned out, reaction wise. All there is, is Naylor Naylor Naylor... admittedly, I feel sorry for him, making a fairly innocent fanpic that winds up with such a huge negative reaction simply because he was the one who did it, but still, it's the fact that he did it that got it such a reaction. It's kinda daunting.
-(Chooses one of the other pics - any of them - to comment on)- I love the D&D Pic with Twilight Sparkle's 'dress of fail'. It is so wizardy, and yet so awesome. Snips and Snails working in a broach shop like a couple of mechanics is just awesome, as well. And in regards to the Derpy Hooves pics - Happy Derpy Day everybody! There! Now leave Naylor alone!
@Pecan
I suspect a lot of the criticism is specifically because it is Naylor.
The image itself is alright, not really sure if I like the style or not. Don't care for how Applejack or Pinkie looks but I do like how Twilight and Rarity are portrayed.
Ah, Ditzy on the airplane wing. I always wish stuff would happen when I sit in an airplane...
@Putuk
>your face when stuff happens while you sit in an airplane
@Anonymous
not at all true >.>
As Shatner would say it...
There's... aderpyonthewing... you... havetobeliveme!
@Don_ko Yeah, looks like that chick that was parodying Tom Sawyer.
The corruption of Jay Naylor is spreading....
@Anonymous
Because while I am okay with Twilight with darker skin she does not have to be such.
@Naxts
Jay Naylor is a very talented artist and even a fair storymaker that has sadly fallen prey to wasting his time on making porn and leaving his main comics to suffer.
Just search New World by Jay Naylor to see what I mean on his potental and compare it to his Better Days comic.
Also some of his misconceptions on government and his... political views have bleed over to MLP FiM. Just read his One Pony comic to see what I mean: http://www.furaffinity.net/view/7292186/
I even make a post where I had Celestia made an actual reply to Big Mac's letter.
Post a Comment